rent extraction
Earning unearned income by leveraging control over a market or system rather than by creating new value.
As defined in 341 | Stewart Brand on Maintenance as an Organizing Principle
Where it comes up · 4
- 341 | Stewart Brand on Maintenance as an Organizing Principle2 claims
- The Moat Portfolio1 claim
- Vitalik Buterin1 claim
- Noah Smith on Worker Compensation, Co-determination, and Market Power1 claim
Most important claims · 5 of 5Search all claims for “rent extraction” →
- Whether increased corporate market power is the culprit for the wage slowdown and falling labor share is uncertain and completely unresolved—economists like the Economic Policy Institute and Jason Furman argue concentration is only a small piece, while papers by David Autor and Simcha Barkai argue declining labor's share comes substantially from concentration and rising rent extraction.Noah Smith on Worker Compensation, Co-determination, and Market Power
- When companies make more money repairing products than selling them—as car dealerships did before Tesla—incentives become perverse: firms may design devices that look great but soon require service from shops and parts they control, extracting unearned rents; this short-term income strategy ultimately loses because satisfied customers are fundamental and dissatisfied ones eventually abandon you.341 | Stewart Brand on Maintenance as an Organizing Principle
- The right-to-repair movement holds that if you buy and own a device you must be able to fix it—otherwise you don't really own it and shouldn't have paid a purchase price; companies like John Deere, once famous for repairable tractors, now make repair difficult and expensive to extract more income, but this is short-term gain that erodes long-term customer loyalty.341 | Stewart Brand on Maintenance as an Organizing Principle
- Although the time for price disequilibria to snap back has fallen from about 1 second in 2000 to about 50 milliseconds, high-frequency-trading profits have stayed roughly constant, because the rate of rent extraction depends on the arms race between canceling stale orders and snapping up mispriced ones—not on absolute technological speed—so the rate of profit and social loss is independent of speed.Vitalik Buterin
- A network effect does not persist on its own; it must be cared for and fed through continued investment. OpenTable's share declined because its owner under-invested in tools, while competitors such as Reserve innovated and OpenTable extracted too many rents from users.The Moat Portfolio