relatively absolute absolutes
Frank Knight's concept (via Buchanan) that some principles are accepted as fixed for practical purposes most of the time, while remaining open to revision when the underlying rules themselves prove bad.
As defined in Michael Munger on the Perfect vs. the Good
Other definitions
Buchanan's term for inherited rules and conditions treated as the binding status quo because they have stood the test of time, even though none is truly sacrosanct and any can be questioned and changed.
Michael Munger on Constitutions
Where it comes up · 4
- Michael Munger on Constitutions1 claim
- Michael Munger on Industrial Policy1 claim
- Michael Munger on the Perfect vs. the Good1 claim
- Michael Munger on Obedience to the Unenforceable1 claim
Most important claims · 4 of 4Search all claims for “relatively absolute absolutes” →
- Frank Knight's concept of 'relatively absolute absolutes,' encountered through Buchanan, offers a middle path between directionalism and destinationism: most of the time accept the rules as given and choose the best policies under them, but sometimes recognize the rules themselves are bad and demand large-scale change—emphasizing rules over the day-to-day churn of outcomes.Michael Munger on the Perfect vs. the Good
- The principal-agent / mechanism-design view that we can simply design and impose a set of rules to optimize outcomes is probably wrong, because there is no unified 'we,' and we do not know enough to know the mapping from institutions into outcomes; we must instead rely on emergent norms (Buchanan's 'relatively absolute absolutes,' Smith's 'sense of propriety').Michael Munger on Obedience to the Unenforceable
- Buchanan shifts the burden of justification from the level of rules to the change in rules: the status quo is the one outcome that requires no one to vote for it to be binding, so what requires consent is altering the Relatively Absolute Absolutes, even though some inherited rules (racism, patriarchy) are indefensible—making this the weakest part of his theory.Michael Munger on Constitutions
- Following Samuel Beer, every system is in an evolutionary sense designed to produce the outcomes it is currently producing, so existing institutions and incentives have over time come to yield these outcomes and not others.Michael Munger on Industrial Policy