relative age effect
The phenomenon where being born early in a selection cohort's age window confers a lasting developmental advantage, here illustrated by NHL players born in January.
As defined in Nate Silver
Where it comes up · 3
- A Perspective with Malcolm Gladwell4 claims
- Malcolm Gladwell Is Lord Of All Things Overlooked and Misunderstood | Rich Roll Podcast1 claim
- Nate Silver1 claim
Most important claims · 6 of 6Search all claims for “relative age effect” →
- The 'relative age effect' in youth sports (children born early in the selection year appear older/more developed and are selected for elite training, then compound this initial advantage with superior coaching, practice, and competition, eventually becoming genuinely elite) demonstrates how arbitrary initial advantages are institutionally amplified into real ones.A Perspective with Malcolm Gladwell
- The relative age effect in youth sports: due to age cutoffs, children who are developmentally behind their peers or born late in the cohort year are systematically disadvantaged and often leave the sport, eliminating late-bloomers from elite pipelines.Malcolm Gladwell Is Lord Of All Things Overlooked and Misunderstood | Rich Roll Podcast
- Drawing on Freakonomics, hockey players born in January have a powerful advantage over those born in November or December simply because they start slightly earlier than their peer group; if such a minor factor profoundly affects outcomes, then a far more identity-central factor like growing up gay in a non-accepting society—requiring large amounts of energy and bandwidth—plausibly creates a comparative disadvantage that suppresses the number of openly gay elite athletes.Nate Silver
- Despite publishing evidence about the relative age effect in 'Outliers' in 2008, and the subsequent public attention to the problem, Canadian junior hockey (and youth sports systems generally) have made no changes to address the bias 15 years later, with the 2022 Canadian junior hockey roster showing the same birth-month distribution problem as pre-2008.A Perspective with Malcolm Gladwell
- Despite clear evidence that meritocratic systems fail (NIH grant scoring, LSAT design, surgical attribution, relative age effect), institutions remain 'powerfully incurious' about fixing these problems, suggesting systemic resistance rather than ignorance.A Perspective with Malcolm Gladwell
- The high concentration of elite players born in early calendar months in the 2007 Medicine Hat Tigers (a major junior hockey team) was the original observation that prompted the Outliers book's discussion of the relative age effect.A Perspective with Malcolm Gladwell