regulatory state
The system of government agencies and administrative bodies that create and enforce detailed regulations, which Ferguson argues has grown sclerotic and overly legalistic.
As defined in 145 | Niall Ferguson on Histories, Networks, and Catastrophes
Where it comes up · 3
- Vivek Ramaswamy3 claims
- Lee Ohanian, Arnold Kling, and John Cochrane on the Future of Freedom, Democracy, and Prosperity2 claims
- 145 | Niall Ferguson on Histories, Networks, and Catastrophes2 claims
Most important claims · 7 of 7Search all claims for “regulatory state” →
- The American bureaucracy produced endless pandemic preparedness reports and PowerPoint decks before 2020, and the US and UK were ranked best-prepared at the end of 2019, yet the systems failed utterly at the point of contact—revealing that the regulatory state wards off disaster through a magical generation of paperwork that is illusory preparation, the same pathology that left banks over-leveraged before 2008.145 | Niall Ferguson on Histories, Networks, and Catastrophes
- Three recent Supreme Court cases make the regulatory state newly vulnerable: West Virginia v. EPA (2022) holds that major policy questions cannot be decided by unelected regulators if Congress hasn't passed them into law, meaning most federal regulations are unconstitutional; Loper-Bright (2024) overturned Chevron Deference so courts no longer defer to agencies' interpretation of law; and SEC v. Jarkesy ended in-agency tribunals that violated separation of powers—a seismic combined impact unavailable to Trump in 2016.Vivek Ramaswamy
- The administrative state since the 1970s evolved by Congress punting hard problems to a proliferation of agencies (now over 60), all sharing a legalistic bureaucratic mentality that demands multi-page regulatory frameworks even for 0.01% probability events—a pathology rooted in the primacy of law schools in educating the administrative class, which crowds out the discretion and delegation that produce anti-fragility.145 | Niall Ferguson on Histories, Networks, and Catastrophes
- The chief threat to rule of law and economic and political freedom comes from the regulatory state, whose vast and increasingly politicized power already silences opposition—no bank dares speak against Dodd-Frank, no health insurer against Obamacare—making regulators the 'barons' of our era who use their power for political support.Lee Ohanian, Arnold Kling, and John Cochrane on the Future of Freedom, Democracy, and Prosperity
- Ramaswamy's ideology in a nutshell is to terminate the nanny state in all its forms—the entitlement state, the regulatory state, and the foreign policy nanny state (subsidizing other countries that don't pay their fair share)—which he frames as a crusade that, once accomplished, revives the republic the founders envisioned.Vivek Ramaswamy
- Pulling off a 75% reduction in the size, scale, regulatory state, and headcount of the federal government only happens if it is the administration's top priority, because such deep cuts create unavoidable clunkiness and frictional costs that will trade off against the effectiveness of other policy goals.Vivek Ramaswamy
- The remedy for the regulatory state's threat to freedom is a new Magna Carta or Bill of Rights for the regulatory state as it has evolved, including procedural protections such as a right to a speedy decision—if a regulatory decision is not rendered within a set time, the applicant has the right to proceed.Lee Ohanian, Arnold Kling, and John Cochrane on the Future of Freedom, Democracy, and Prosperity