recovery (as political identity)
In Schellenberger's framing, a political-philosophical position emphasizing human agency, improvement potential, and empowerment as opposed to permanent victimhood; used as organizing concept for coalitions seeking to move people from street addiction toward self-sufficiency
As defined in Michael Shellenberger - Why Progressives Ruin Cities
Where it comes up · 1
Most important claims · 6 of 6Search all claims for “recovery (as political identity)” →
- Cost comparison shows that providing group home treatment with case management and relapse accommodation is cheaper than the current California system of repeated EMT/Narcan interventions, fire truck dispatches, and re-arrests without recovery, making the recovery approach economically superiorMichael Shellenberger - Why Progressives Ruin Cities
- 'Overdetermined' (the idea that something has so many contributing causes that it is over-explained) is the appropriate frame for understanding why San Francisco hasn't adopted intervention-treatment-recovery models, since multiple factors—voter attitudes, judges, city councils, state legislators, institutions, money, and power—all resist change, but fundamentally an ideology of victimhood drives the resistance.Michael Shellenberger - Why Progressives Ruin Cities
- The key missing component in California's homeless services system is consistent case management: a caseworker assigned to each person from police intervention through psychiatric hospital to group homes, providing continuity of care and coordinating family, judges, psychiatrists, and recovery programs as one integrated team.Michael Shellenberger - Why Progressives Ruin Cities
- Most people living on streets need 1-2 years in group homes with recovery and rehab (like the Village of Hope model) plus job placement and family reconnection; only 10-20% require long-term psychiatric wards; this is basic nursing and psychiatric care, not complex.Michael Shellenberger - Why Progressives Ruin Cities
- A coalition Schellenberger works with ('North America Recovers') brings together previously opposing groups: residents fed up with open drug scenes, parents of homeless addicts, recovering addicts, and evidence-based psychiatric care providers, united by the goal of intervention-treatment-recovery.Michael Shellenberger - Why Progressives Ruin Cities
- Public opinion polls show 70-80% of Californians support the intervention-treatment-recovery policy agenda, including in San Francisco where 75% support mandated treatment, providing strong electoral support for politicians who adopt these positions.Michael Shellenberger - Why Progressives Ruin Cities