real patterns
Dennett's idea that ways of describing the world at higher levels of abstraction, even if only approximate, count as real if they capture genuine regularities.
As defined in 178 | Jody Azzouni on What Is and Isn't Real
Where it comes up · 6
- 33 | James Ladyman on Reality, Metaphysics, and Complexity4 claims
- 78 | Daniel Dennett on Minds, Patterns, and the Scientific Image2 claims
- 178 | Jody Azzouni on What Is and Isn't Real1 claim
- 295 | Solo: Emergence and Layers of Reality1 claim
- AMA | April 20221 claim
- AMA | September 20211 claim
Most important claims · 10 of 10Search all claims for “real patterns” →
- In the physicist's sense (weak emergence), higher-level descriptions speak different vocabularies but remain compatible with lower levels because they exploit patterns implicit in the microscopic dynamics; the center-of-mass example shows that throwing away almost all microscopic information still yields good predictions only because the retained information is extraordinarily special—keeping random information would predict nothing—making emergence a wonderful, non-trivial feature of nature rather than the strong emergence where macro behavior cannot be derived from micro at all.AMA | September 2021
- Following structural realism (Ladyman and Ross) and Dennett's 'real patterns,' the patterns preserved as you move between higher and lower level theories are themselves real, so emergent higher-level entities like tables and chairs genuinely exist; a definition of reality not broad enough to include tables and chairs is the wrong definition.295 | Solo: Emergence and Layers of Reality
- The touchstone of whether a pattern is real is whether you can make money betting on it—if it is predictive, it is real—and every other real/unreal distinction (real vs fictional, real vs bogus) is somehow dependent on this predictive test.78 | Daniel Dennett on Minds, Patterns, and the Scientific Image
- Higher-level emergent structures, what Dan Dennett calls 'real patterns,' are precious and rare in the space of all possible coarse-grainings because they provide enormous predictive power on the basis of very little input data; you can predict a table will hold a coffee cup without knowing anything about its individual atoms, and such useful patterns are few among all possible bases for describing the world.AMA | April 2022
- A pattern is real if it provides predictive leverage—a concise summary that lets you do better than a coin flip about the next bit of data—and the amount of compression possible (vs storing every pixel of random data) measures how much real pattern exists; this gives patterns a clear, mathematically formulable reality criterion.78 | Daniel Dennett on Minds, Patterns, and the Scientific Image
- What is real is what is indispensable to talk about in order to capture information about the world and make predictions and explanations; on this view it makes no sense to say something is real but cannot be used to predict or explain anything, tying reality to non-redundant information efficiency.33 | James Ladyman on Reality, Metaphysics, and Complexity
- On the real-patterns view the pattern is primary and the 'thing' is just a way of identifying or talking about the pattern; whenever we investigate actual things they turn out to be collections of relations among other things, so relations may go all the way down, and we should not assume otherwise.33 | James Ladyman on Reality, Metaphysics, and Complexity
- Empirical accuracy of a characterization is not evidence that everything it mathematically posits exists; what exists is what we have thick epistemic access to (instrumental, manipulation access), so emergent mid-level patterns can be real while the mathematical formalism (e.g. a Hilbert space vector) used to describe them, however accurate, is not.178 | Jody Azzouni on What Is and Isn't Real
- The parts of a table compose a real object because they hang together dynamically and let you track behavior efficiently, whereas an arbitrary compound (e.g. a left earlobe plus Miles Davis' last solo plus the largest elephant in Namibia) gives no extra purchase on the world over treating its parts separately, so it does not count as a bona fide object.33 | James Ladyman on Reality, Metaphysics, and Complexity
- The real-patterns criterion gives a unified account of reality across common sense and science: a table is real because I need to talk about it to get by, and the Andromeda galaxy is real because I need to talk about it to systematize my observations of the universe.33 | James Ladyman on Reality, Metaphysics, and Complexity