randomized trial
An experiment in which participants are randomly assigned to conditions to estimate causal impact of an intervention.
As defined in Mark Zuckerberg Interviews Patrick Collison And Tyler Cowen
Where it comes up · 4
- Anupam Bapu Jena on Random Acts of Medicine3 claims
- Emily Oster on Pregnancy, Causation, and Expecting Better2 claims
- 256 - A Contagion Of Bad Ideas2 claims
- Mark Zuckerberg Interviews Patrick Collison And Tyler Cowen1 claim
Most important claims · 8 of 8Search all claims for “randomized trial” →
- The ivermectin-for-COVID evidence rests on small trials totaling about 2,200 participants, with the largest (from Egypt) shown by Gideon Meyerowitz-Katz to be highly irregular and likely fraudulent—including patients already dead before recruitment—so while there may be a weak signal worth pursuing, claims that ivermectin is 99% effective or reduces mortality by 70-90% are impossible and unsupported.256 - A Contagion Of Bad Ideas
- Even non-experts can adjudicate this dispute by weighing the totality of evidence: hundreds of thousands of participants in randomized, double-blind vaccine trials plus overwhelming safety data, versus roughly 2,200 people across all ivermectin trials—a vast asymmetry in the weight of evidence that should guide any data-driven person.256 - A Contagion Of Bad Ideas
- Multiple studies—a Stanford randomized trial in India, Michela Giorcelli's study of Italian firms showing benefits 15 years after management training with natural randomization, and a randomized trial of about 600 firms in Mexico—suggest that simply teaching better management practices makes firms employ more people, pay higher wages, and become more successful, which if true is amazing low-hanging fruit warranting much more investment and study of which practices generalize.Mark Zuckerberg Interviews Patrick Collison And Tyler Cowen
- While faster medical care intuitively seems better, sooner is almost always more costly, and in many situations later care is no worse and substantially cheaper, so the real decision is how much effort to invest in timeliness for a given acute problem—a tradeoff the marathon study helps quantify because nature provides the delay data a randomized trial never could.Anupam Bapu Jena on Random Acts of Medicine
- Because we believe smoking is harmful, ethical randomized trials exist that encourage some pregnant women to quit; when those programs succeed, the babies show large improvements particularly in birth weight, giving causal confirmation that smoking harms the fetus rather than just correlating via confounders.Emily Oster on Pregnancy, Causation, and Expecting Better
- Although economists have used natural experiments for decades and randomized trials are common in medicine, natural experiments—where people are exposed by chance to something like a hurricane, a policy threshold, or their age rather than by an investigator's hand—are not used as often in medicine despite their power to reveal causal effects.Anupam Bapu Jena on Random Acts of Medicine
- To credibly claim a natural experiment, one must first demonstrate that the exposed and unexposed groups are similar on all observable characteristics—demographics, chronic conditions, procedures performed, staffing levels—because any imbalance suggests the exposure was not truly as-good-as-random, and even then a valid experiment establishes the effect but not the mechanism.Anupam Bapu Jena on Random Acts of Medicine
- Around birth there is genuine randomized data—for example trials where some women were encouraged to have an epidural and some not—which allows more confident causal conclusions than observational diet studies, though such trials are run in limited populations and don't measure all outcomes.Emily Oster on Pregnancy, Causation, and Expecting Better