r > g
Shorthand for the rate of return on capital (r) exceeding the economy's growth rate (g); Piketty's central mechanism for rising wealth concentration.
As defined in Thomas Piketty on Inequality and Capital in the 21st Century
Where it comes up · 2
- Daron Acemoglu on Inequality, Institutions, and Piketty4 claims
- Thomas Piketty on Inequality and Capital in the 21st Century1 claim
Most important claims · 5 of 5Search all claims for “r > g” →
- The central force driving long-run wealth concentration is the tendency of the rate of return on capital (r) to exceed the economy's growth rate (g): when r exceeds g, wealth owners can consume most of their return, reinvest a small fraction, and still have their fortune grow as fast as the economy, so the larger the r-g gap the more inequality and the less social mobility, all else equal.Thomas Piketty on Inequality and Capital in the 21st Century
- Focusing on r-g leaves out far more important institutional determinants of inequality, as illustrated by Sweden and South Africa: both saw huge 20th-century swings in inequality, none of which is related to r-g or to wars and the destruction of capital, but all of which is deeply institutional—the formation of the Swedish social welfare state and the apartheid regime in South Africa that held black wages down while redistributing to whites, then its collapse.Daron Acemoglu on Inequality, Institutions, and Piketty
- Piketty's 'central contradiction of capitalism' is misnamed because r>g is implied by economic efficiency: in growth theory, economies where r is less than or equal to g are called dynamically inefficient because savers are not properly compensated and the economy generates too much capital, so that everyone could be made better off by consuming some of it; thus r>g is exactly what a market economy should and generally does generate, not a newly discovered fault line of capitalism.Daron Acemoglu on Inequality, Institutions, and Piketty
- Piketty does a fantastic job unearthing informative tax-return data on inequality, but he violates the empirical literature's standard practice of testing claims through correlations and regressions and then worrying about causality; instead he lays out striking patterns and asserts they are explained by r-g or the World Wars without ever doing cross-country, over-time, or cross-household correlations—and when one does a simple correlational check, periods where r exceeds g do not show increasing inequality.Daron Acemoglu on Inequality, Institutions, and Piketty
- A positive r-g does not imply increasing inequality because not everyone is a capital owner all the time—people save for life-cycle reasons or to pass wealth to lower-earning children—and social mobility (both intergenerational and within-lifetime, such as being a high earner in your 40s then living off savings in your 60s) breaks the link between the return on capital and where capital owners end up, so the connection between r-g and inexorably rising wealth inequality is tenuous at best.Daron Acemoglu on Inequality, Institutions, and Piketty