qualitative vs quantitative
The distinction between qualities (experiential characters like color or smell) and quantities (mathematically describable features like size, shape, motion); central to Goff's framing of the consciousness problem.
As defined in 71 | Philip Goff on Consciousness Everywhere
Where it comes up · 1
Most important claims · 4 of 4Search all claims for “qualitative vs quantitative” →
- Physical science has been so successful precisely because it was designed from the outset to deal only with quantities and to set consciousness outside its domain; therefore the common inference that science's track record guarantees it will eventually explain consciousness does not follow, because it is being asked to do the one thing it was constructed to exclude.71 | Philip Goff on Consciousness Everywhere
- Inferring that physics will explain consciousness because it has been so successful commits a fallacy of extrapolating beyond a domain of competence: physics is impressive only at the limited task of describing the behavior of matter via mathematical models, never at accounting for subjective qualities, just as being good at teaching and research gives no reason to expect being good at administration.71 | Philip Goff on Consciousness Everywhere
- The core of the problem of consciousness is that physical science works with a purely quantitative vocabulary, whereas consciousness is essentially qualitative (the redness of red, the smell of coffee), and you cannot capture these qualities in the quantitative language of neuroscience, so any purely quantitative description of the brain misses an essential component of consciousness.71 | Philip Goff on Consciousness Everywhere
- Galileo's founding move in mathematizing science was a philosophical theory that relocated qualities (color, smell, taste) out of the physical world and into the consciousness of the observer, which he placed outside the domain of science; this left only quantitative properties (size, shape, location, motion) in the physical world, creating a radical dualism between quantitative physical reality and qualitative consciousness.71 | Philip Goff on Consciousness Everywhere