pushing on a string
Monetary policy constraint where central banks cannot stimulate demand when interest rates are already at zero or low; further money expansion has diminishing returns because it doesn't create spending demand (like pushing on a rope that goes slack)
As defined in China’s Economic House Of Cards Is Collapsing | Brian McCarthy
Where it comes up · 2
- People Don’t Realize ‘How Bad This Could Get’; Gold To $7,000 In Dollar Crisis4 claims
- China’s Economic House Of Cards Is Collapsing | Brian McCarthy1 claim
Most important claims · 5 of 5Search all claims for “pushing on a string” →
- Even with rate cuts to neutral or below, stimulus doesn't automatically translate to economic acceleration; Canada is experiencing a balance sheet recession despite rates at the neutral rate, showing the limits of monetary policy.People Don’t Realize ‘How Bad This Could Get’; Gold To $7,000 In Dollar Crisis
- The Fed funds rate and Bank of Canada rate are now at neutral (r-star), yet Canada is experiencing a balance sheet recession with 'pushing on a string' dynamics (flat LM curve where monetary policy can't stimulate), but the US is different because American consumers are less levered up and the economy has more growth capacity.People Don’t Realize ‘How Bad This Could Get’; Gold To $7,000 In Dollar Crisis
- The present day bond market faces secular deflationary pressures from excessive debt levels, making the risk of deflation (not inflation) the greater danger if policy tightens; pre-COVID, secular stagnation prevented inflation despite years of QEPeople Don’t Realize ‘How Bad This Could Get’; Gold To $7,000 In Dollar Crisis
- The key difference between fiscal policy (government borrowing and spending more than taxes) and monetary policy (central bank balance sheet expansion) is that monetary policy alone can 'push on a string' in deflation without generating inflation, but fiscal policy creates real aggregate demand and must be paired with monetary policy for maximum effect.China’s Economic House Of Cards Is Collapsing | Brian McCarthy
- There are foundational deflationary pressures in the current environment (excessive debt, global excess capacity) that could overwhelm inflation from tariffs and fiscal stimulus—secular stagnation pressures are 'still pushing on a string'—so achieving any inflation at all to grow out of the debt is actually desirable and breaking the 'curse of Elvin Hansen' (secular stagnation), and policymakers should not 'grasp defeat from the jaws of victory' by fighting inflation.People Don’t Realize ‘How Bad This Could Get’; Gold To $7,000 In Dollar Crisis