proper time
The time elapsed as measured by a clock traveling along a given worldline; massless particles do not experience proper time.
As defined in AMA | October 2024
Where it comes up · 8
- AMA | December 20202 claims
- AMA | March 20212 claims
- Sean Carroll on the Biggest Ideas in the Universe | Closer To Truth Chats2 claims
- 211 | Solo: Secrets of Einstein's Equation1 claim
- AMA | April 20251 claim
- AMA | March 20251 claim
- AMA | March 20261 claim
- AMA | October 20241 claim
Most important claims · 10 of 11Search all claims for “proper time” →
- Before electroweak symmetry breaking all fundamental particles were massless and moving at the speed of light, so understanding the geometry of that era requires recognizing that massless particles do not have rest frames or experience proper time, requiring a description that does not rely on a particle's own clock.AMA | October 2024
- The argument that because a photon experiences no proper time and zero traveled distance, the destination atom was 'fixed' when it left the source, therefore denying free will, is flawed because there is no valid rest frame for a photon (its frame is degenerate and unphysical), so reasoning from 'the photon's perspective' is illegitimate and yields no conclusion about determinism or free will.AMA | March 2025
- It is nonsense to say time 'flows more slowly' near a black hole or at high speed; time moves at one second per second for every observer, and you should only compare total elapsed proper time when trajectories reconvene, never compare rates of time flow across distant frames.AMA | March 2021
- In special relativity, unlike Newtonian physics where time is absolute and universal, each observer experiences their own personal proper time that depends on the path taken through spacetime; the twin who travels near light speed and returns ages less, and the rule—mirroring Euclid's 'shortest distance is a straight line' but with a sign flip—is that the longest elapsed time corresponds to a straight (unaccelerated) path through spacetime.211 | Solo: Secrets of Einstein's Equation
- Everyone ages at one year per year regardless of trajectory; the differing elapsed time in the twin paradox comes from taking a different path through spacetime, not from acceleration, exactly analogous to walking different distances between two points where you always move one meter per meter but a curved path covers more distance, except in spacetime the straight line is the longest elapsed time.AMA | December 2020
- Time as measured by observers carrying clocks (proper time) is exactly analogous to distance along a path in space: different trajectories between the same two events accumulate different elapsed proper times, so time is not a universal objective flow but a quantity measured along individual paths, with the longest time between two events being the straight-line path.AMA | March 2021
- It is meaningless to speak of a photon's perspective: photons do not experience the passage of time, and since experiencing nothing follows from not experiencing time, measured speeds like 186,000 miles per second are always from our reference frame, not the photon's.AMA | December 2020
- The common claim that anything falling into a black hole never reaches the event horizon within the universe's lifespan reflects only the perspective of a distant observer, for whom the infalling object appears to slow and redshift asymptotically; from the infalling object's own reference frame it crosses the horizon in finite proper time, so the object really does fall in.AMA | April 2025
- Because the far-away-observer clock runs increasingly ahead as a spaceship approaches the event horizon (eventually billions of years before crossing), it might seem objects never fall into a black hole but rather fall onto it, possibly implying there is no actual central singularity.AMA | March 2026
- A common misconception about special relativity is saying 'clocks move more slowly when traveling at high speeds,' but more precisely: time passes at one second per second for every observer, and time dilation is a relative effect—from different reference frames, different amounts of proper time accumulate, not because time is 'actually' slower but because of the geometry of spacetime.Sean Carroll on the Biggest Ideas in the Universe | Closer To Truth Chats