principled moral restraint
Refraining from a negative moral act because it is wrong in and of itself, independent of any harm it causes or of being caught.
As defined in David Rose on the Moral Foundations of Economic Behavior
Where it comes up · 1
Most important claims · 3 of 3Search all claims for “principled moral restraint” →
- Principled moral restraint—refusing a negative moral act not because of the harm it does but because it is wrong in and of itself—solves the empathy problem; the candy-bar thought experiment shows people will not steal even when guaranteed to get away with it, demonstrating that genuine restraint is not contingent on detection or harm.David Rose on the Moral Foundations of Economic Behavior
- Studies show student cheating has risen dramatically over 25 years, and crucially the justification has changed: where students once admitted cheating was wrong but felt compelled, a shockingly high proportion now ask 'what's the big deal?' and argue nobody was hurt—indicating a shift toward the absence of principled moral restraint rather than mere rule-breaking.David Rose on the Moral Foundations of Economic Behavior
- Solving the greater good rationalization problem requires both principled moral restraint and lexical primacy together to produce duty-based moral restraint, because without principled restraint the enabling negative act will not even be regarded as wrong when no one is harmed, and without lexical primacy a moral person may still trade it for a greater good.David Rose on the Moral Foundations of Economic Behavior