preprint
A scientific manuscript posted publicly (e.g., on a preprint server) before formal peer review and journal publication.
As defined in 108 | Carl Bergstrom on Information, Disinformation, and Bullshit
Other definitions
A manuscript that has been finished and passed peer review but is released publicly before formal publication in a journal or conference, intended to speed dissemination; increasingly misused by companies to release unreviewed research directly to media and public
Authors of "THE AI CON" discussing the problematic hype about AI & what those working tech should do
Where it comes up · 6
- 108 | Carl Bergstrom on Information, Disinformation, and Bullshit2 claims
- Authors of "THE AI CON" discussing the problematic hype about AI & what those working tech should do2 claims
- Dwarkesh Patel Podcast - Michael Nielsen – How science actually progresses1 claim
- 425 - Are We Prepared For The Next Pandemic1 claim
- 411 - The Victimhood Pandemic1 claim
- 324 | Elizabeth Mynatt on Universities and the Importance of Basic Research1 claim
Most important claims · 8 of 8Search all claims for “preprint” →
- Virus hunting—searching wildlife reservoirs for novel viruses—has not been valuable for vaccine development, because we have failed to find most reservoirs even of known human pathogens, the discovery of new animal viruses has never historically prompted development of vaccines against them, and serious vaccine development only begins after an actual outbreak, often only when it affects rich Westerners.425 - Are We Prepared For The Next Pandemic
- COVID-19 prompted the most massively open science ever—raw data, preprints, and code shared early on open boards—but because the topic is hyperpoliticized, every paper lands on one side of the political spectrum and gets used as a cudgel, so even when one side's evidence outweighs another's, tribe members won't concede for fear of being seen as belonging to the other tribe.108 | Carl Bergstrom on Information, Disinformation, and Bullshit
- Preprint servers radically compress the timeline between putting an idea out and having it adopted and critiqued by the community from about a year to a few days, as Bergstrom found when a physics paper posted to the arXiv drew unsolicited expert feedback within a week, making openness a clear net good for science.108 | Carl Bergstrom on Information, Disinformation, and Bullshit
- Academic papers published as preprints by tech companies (Microsoft, Anthropic, OpenAI) on their own websites bypass peer review entirely, violating the original purpose of preprints and undermining the gatekeeping function of peer review that ensures scientific rigor.Authors of "THE AI CON" discussing the problematic hype about AI & what those working tech should do
- Scientific publishing paywalls are falling because researchers want open access but are constrained by journal economics; the pandemic accelerated open preprint sharing (e.g., arXiv) in an all-hands-on-deck emergency, and professional bodies like the ACM are now shifting to open models and finding alternative revenue, making the open-access genie impossible to put back in the bottle.324 | Elizabeth Mynatt on Universities and the Importance of Basic Research
- Science faces a dual chilling effect: the Trump administration is purging funding and research using flagged keywords, while residual wokeism forces papers through 'sensitivity readings' and preprint sites reject papers on certain topics (e.g., the personality traits of Trump conservatives), so both forces combine to harm honest research.411 - The Victimhood Pandemic
- Papers published by AI companies (Microsoft, Anthropic, OpenAI) as 'preprints' circumvent peer review by not submitting to traditional publishing processes, allowing companies to release 'paper-shaped objects' that would not meet scientific rigor standards directly to the world with significant media attention.Authors of "THE AI CON" discussing the problematic hype about AI & what those working tech should do
- The credit/attribution economy of science is something we construct by agreement, not a natural fact: it took over a century to move from Galileo and Kepler publishing discoveries as scrambled anagrams to the modern paper-plus-attribution reputation economy; today we can share code, data, and in-progress ideas but with no agreed credit, and any change to that economy yields a different system for constructing knowledge — illustrated by physicists and biologists giving opposite competitiveness rationales for preprint culture.Dwarkesh Patel Podcast - Michael Nielsen – How science actually progresses