positive selection
When the migrants leaving a population are systematically more able, skilled, or higher-status than those who stay, raising the average quality of the migrant group.
As defined in Gregory Clark
Where it comes up · 3
- Gregory Clark6 claims
- Alex Rampell - Investing in Operating Systems - [Invest Like the Best, EP. 248]2 claims
- Brett Harrison — FTX US former president speaks out1 claim
Most important claims · 9 of 9Search all claims for “positive selection” →
- In venture capital, being consensus right is often better than being non-consensus right, and investors should lean into positive selection (deals where many strong investors compete) and avoid adverse selection (deals where few bidders show up, signaling something is wrong).Alex Rampell - Investing in Operating Systems - [Invest Like the Best, EP. 248]
- In private markets, if you are the only bidder for a hard-to-win deal, that is a sign of adverse selection, because a good company limited to a few firms would be expected to attract multiple competing bids, while a great sign is when the other invited firms are highly interested and you must pay a higher price than you'd like.Alex Rampell - Investing in Operating Systems - [Invest Like the Best, EP. 248]
- Hiring differs from adverse selection in trading: it offers many more opportunities for positive selection, and unlike liquid US financial markets the hiring market is highly inefficient, so a resume from an unknown university with no internships could be the best candidate in an entire region and represent positive rather than adverse selection; strong mission-driven brands (like Jane Street's) convert a once-poor recruiting pipeline into a positively-selected one without the underlying talent pool changing.Brett Harrison — FTX US former president speaks out
- When people move from Britain to Australia, Canada, or the United States, their material welfare increases very significantly, but their relative social position does not change and is somehow preserved across these different societies—showing physical mobility raises absolute outcomes without altering relative rank.Gregory Clark
- Surname analysis shows nearly all European-descended groups in the US are very average, indicating 19th-century migration out of Europe was not strongly selected; the evidence even shows Scandinavian and possibly Irish emigration was negatively selected, while Quebec French-speakers became a US underclass—contrasting with the strong positive selection of Chinese, Indian, and Jewish immigrants who form the new American elite.Gregory Clark
- The growth of the South of England and decline of the North is entirely attributable to self-selection within Britain: more talented and able people out-migrate from places like Glasgow and the North, while less skilled people migrate the other way, so apparent regional differences reflect who moved rather than place effects.Gregory Clark
- A generous welfare system with high taxes selects against the most productive immigrants because it does not reward making it on your own; the United States, by allowing people to get richer and stay richer, attracts high-performing immigrants like Indian CEOs, whereas immigrants to Denmark have not responded to its welfare system the same way as natives.Gregory Clark
- Post-1960 immigration is dramatically transforming English society: white British are becoming the lower class while Africans, Bangladeshis, Pakistanis, and particularly Hindu Indians and Chinese form substantial new upper classes; because immigrant fertility is higher, a large fraction of 15-year-olds now come from these origins, which complicates calculating social mobility rates but has been an enormous benefit to English society.Gregory Clark
- Among migrants from Latin America to the United States, the further away the origin country is from the US, the better the migrants tend to do and the more positively selected they are (e.g., Chileans are strongly positively selected)—consistent with a distance-based selection effect.Gregory Clark