positive deviance
Within a group facing the same constraints, the individuals who deviate from the norm by finding an uncommon but successful solution to a shared problem; identifying and validating them lets their solution spread to peers.
As defined in Mauricio Miller on Poverty, Social Work, and the Alternative
Where it comes up · 1
Most important claims · 5 of 5Search all claims for “positive deviance” →
- After Javier and Maria bought a house, the other refugee families reasoned 'if they can buy a house, we can buy a house' and within 18 months every Salvadoran refugee family in the group owned a home, and word-of-mouth spread the change through the wider community — demonstrating that a single successful 'positive deviant' from a peer group changes the trajectory of expectations far more powerfully than expert intervention.Mauricio Miller on Poverty, Social Work, and the Alternative
- Telling a low-income person they are an expert and asking others to seek their advice is enormously motivating; almost anyone who is low-income loves being treated as a capable adviser, so validating positive deviants as experts mobilizes peer-to-peer help and eliminates the need for large trained staff.Mauricio Miller on Poverty, Social Work, and the Alternative
- By refusing to let staff intervene with the Javier and Maria family facing a predatory mortgage, FII allowed the family to find a solution staff never could have devised — using a refinance clause and mobilizing friends to renovate and raise the home's value — demonstrating that protecting people from mistakes also denies them the chance to build equity and discover their own paths.Mauricio Miller on Poverty, Social Work, and the Alternative
- To learn the true capacity of poor families and how much they help each other, Miller enrolled them only in groups of friends, required them to turn to each other rather than staff, and forbade staff from helping (firing those who did) — applying an engineer's demand for clean data uncontaminated by outsider intervention.Mauricio Miller on Poverty, Social Work, and the Alternative
- Within the same FII cohort, distinct ethnic groups pursued different self-chosen success measures: African-American families raised income most (37% in two years) and started businesses, Salvadoran refugees (23% income gain) bought homes, and the Iu Mien Asian group (18% income gain) redirected children from gangs into four-year colleges — showing that success is not just income and that people should choose which problems matter most to them.Mauricio Miller on Poverty, Social Work, and the Alternative