positional pre-eminence
Status defined relative to others — being ranked above other people in fame, honor, or rank — rather than by intrinsic accomplishment.
As defined in Martha Nussbaum on Alexander Hamilton
Where it comes up · 1
Most important claims · 3 of 3Search all claims for “positional pre-eminence” →
- Following Rawls, envy is less destabilizing to democracy when people are shown their efforts can bear fruit and when the gap between top and bottom is narrowed; a society or institution (like a high school) avoids becoming a cauldron of envy by offering many different paths to positional achievement — in sports, arts, scholarship, and service — rather than a single hierarchy with a few at the top and everyone else in the outer darkness.Martha Nussbaum on Alexander Hamilton
- Envy is a painful emotion focused on others enjoying good things you lack, distinct from jealousy which is about competition for a particular rival and can be satisfied; envy opens a bottomless pit of hopelessness toward the good things of life and, if sufficiently widespread, can destabilize a democracy committed to mobility and the pursuit of happiness.Martha Nussbaum on Alexander Hamilton
- Ancient Stoic philosophers reframed the classic Hercules myth so that the choice was no longer between virtue and mere pleasure but between a life of virtue and creation versus a life of fame and positional pre-eminence (being the insider everyone talks about), because the pleasure version was an obvious loser as a persuasive device for young people.Martha Nussbaum on Alexander Hamilton