pleiotropy
When a single gene has more than one effect, often in different parts of the body.
As defined in 195 | Richard Dawkins on Flight and Other Evolutionary Achievements
Where it comes up · 6
- Steve Hsu - Intelligence, Embryo Selection, & The Future of Humanity4 claims
- 211 - The Nature Of Human Nature2 claims
- 128 - Transformations Of Mind2 claims
- 195 | Richard Dawkins on Flight and Other Evolutionary Achievements2 claims
- 106 - Humanity 2.01 claim
- 296 | Brandon Ogbunu on Fitness Seascapes and the Course of Evolution1 claim
Most important claims · 10 of 12Search all claims for “pleiotropy” →
- Genetic influence on complex traits and common disorders is due to thousands of tiny DNA differences each with minuscule effects, not one or a hundred genes; rare single-gene Mendelian disorders are deterministic but uncommon and contribute little to the heritability of common traits.211 - The Nature Of Human Nature
- Certain alleles that correlate with increased intelligence may also correlate with diseases nobody wants, so a parent enhancing a child's intelligence might face a trade-off of raising the odds of debilitating disease in exchange for brain power.106 - Humanity 2.0
- Even if some intelligence-boosting variants have undesirable correlated effects (autism, dullness, weakness), the sheer number of variants (~10,000-20,000) means a skilled genetic engineer can simply select a different cluster of variants to 'drive around' any obstacle, as evidenced by historical geniuses who were also athletic and socially capable—proving such combinations exist.Steve Hsu - Intelligence, Embryo Selection, & The Future of Humanity
- Every DNA difference has many effects (pleiotropy), so genes named after one disorder, such as a diabetes gene, turn out to affect hundreds of other things, complicating any simple gene-to-trait mapping.211 - The Nature Of Human Nature
- Contrary to naive expectations of widespread pleiotropy, the genomic regions controlling different disease conditions show very modest overlap—they are largely disjoint—because with 3 billion base pairs there is enough information for roughly 1000 independent traits, each controlled by its own disjoint set of variants.Steve Hsu - Intelligence, Embryo Selection, & The Future of Humanity
- Contrary to expectations a decade ago that trait genetics would be highly nonlinear with many interaction terms, the genetic architecture of individual differences turned out to be largely additive—predictors that simply sum effect sizes across variant states work well—reflecting a deep and under-appreciated truth that the ways humans differ are mostly a matter of having more or less of additive switches rather than complex interactions.Steve Hsu - Intelligence, Embryo Selection, & The Future of Humanity
- Dawkins-era antagonistic-pleiotropy stories about aging (a gene helping when young but harming when old) are true for some specific variants like sickle cell, but they are not the general story; the general finding from the last five years is that thousands of largely disjoint variants control almost every trait, so old-school evolutionary theorists weren't wrong but lacked the big picture.Steve Hsu - Intelligence, Embryo Selection, & The Future of Humanity
- Genes can have phenotypic effects beyond the body that bears them—the extended phenotype—because structures like elaborately shaped bird nests are Darwinian adaptations requiring genes for nest shape, and the same logic extends to parasites like brain worms that lesion an ant's brain to alter its behavior and make it more likely to be eaten by the parasite's next host, and to cuckoo chicks manipulating foster parents.195 | Richard Dawkins on Flight and Other Evolutionary Achievements
- Once embryo selection technology is vetted as safe and able to amplify unambiguously good traits without raising negative consequences, parents will use it—and the crucial inequality issue in about 20 years will be whether society makes access widespread rather than letting it become the preserve of the rich and well-connected, which would massively amplify inequality.128 - Transformations Of Mind
- China is likely to adopt CRISPR gene editing rapidly given its tradition of 'good birth' and lack of American ethical concerns, but if it selects against mental illnesses like bipolar disorder it could unwittingly select out creativity genes given the substantial overlap between bipolar and creativity, potentially producing a genetically homogenized society that loses its spark.128 - Transformations Of Mind