perils of partial attribution
Pritchett's coined phrase for the analytical error of crediting only directly-measurable effects, ignoring large but hard-to-attribute systemic contributions—leading research and resources toward small measurable questions.
As defined in Lant Pritchett on Poverty, Growth, and Experiments
Where it comes up · 1
Most important claims · 3 of 3Search all claims for “perils of partial attribution” →
- The obsession with directly-attributable causal effects—what Pritchett calls the Perils of Partial Attribution—systematically biases research toward small, easily-measured questions and away from the large systemic factors that actually explain poverty reduction, like focusing on a basketball player's points scored while ignoring his defense, which can make a high scorer a net-negative contributor to team wins.Lant Pritchett on Poverty, Growth, and Experiments
- The free trade consensus was a deliberate, successful 20th-century social movement: thirty years ago countries like India banned consumer imports outright, and advocates consciously used every lever to change beliefs and swept the board—a transformation that no single study can be credited with but which collectively had a huge impact, and which recent revisions only roll back about 2% of the way.Lant Pritchett on Poverty, Growth, and Experiments
- The central question should be how to get a country from a 320 to a 500 in learning outcomes, and answering it requires having defensible presumptions about direction—like Smith's presumption of liberty or 'teaching at the right level'—that produce cumulative huge effects, rather than treating directly-attributable measurability as the criterion for what's important; success is the issue, not being the high scorer.Lant Pritchett on Poverty, Growth, and Experiments