path diagram
A graph of variables connected by arrows representing causal 'listens to' relationships, originally introduced by Sewall Wright and central to Pearl's causal calculus.
As defined in 196 | Judea Pearl on Cause and Effect
Where it comes up · 1
Most important claims · 7 of 7Search all claims for “path diagram” →
- Geneticist Sewall Wright, frustrated that equations did not represent what he meant in the 1920s, introduced an asymmetric assignment-like arrow operator and built path diagrams—anticipating the computer-science distinction between assignment and equality—and was attacked for it but had the audacity to invent a new symbol for a needed concept.196 | Judea Pearl on Cause and Effect
- Causal diagrams are built from a single rudimentary primitive—'listens to'—where you draw an arrow from A to B only if B listens to A (e.g., the barometer deflection listens to atmospheric pressure, the rooster listens to the glow in the sky), combining data with human knowledge to encode who listens to whom.196 | Judea Pearl on Cause and Effect
- The do-operator simulates an action by removing the arrows from a variable's previous causes ('masters') and subjecting it to a new master—the intervener's muscle—setting its value directly, which yields a new diagram that can be solved; this captures the asymmetry between seeing and doing that probability theory cannot express because the do-operator does not exist in probability theory.196 | Judea Pearl on Cause and Effect
- Bringing knowledge in the form of a causal diagram lets you do more than predict the effect of forced action—it tells you which factors you must adjust for (such as gender, family history, or addiction in the family) in order to obtain a causal answer without running an experiment, effectively replacing a randomized experiment with a piece of knowledge.196 | Judea Pearl on Cause and Effect
- A causal path diagram is a parsimonious representation that contains all knowledge about a super-exponentially large number of counterfactuals, so feeding a robot this collection of 'who listens to whom' assumptions is sufficient for it to reason counterfactually—unlike David Lewis's closest-possible-worlds semantics, which requires an infinitely large, computationally infeasible set of inter-world relationships.196 | Judea Pearl on Cause and Effect
- An automated scientist can be built by equipping a robot with a causal diagram plus techniques to enrich it—reasoning conjecturally about what future experiments to conduct and what additional variables to observe to answer questions the current diagram cannot answer—so the diagram must be vulnerable both to refutation by data and to enrichment, all driven by the force of curiosity toward deep understanding.196 | Judea Pearl on Cause and Effect
- A comprehensive set of observational data may not be enough to learn why things happen; to truly learn causal structure you have to play and do experiments, which is why toddlers and babies constantly and restlessly manipulate objects in the crib until they understand why a toy makes noise.196 | Judea Pearl on Cause and Effect