paternalism
Regulation motivated by the belief that people will make bad choices for themselves (e.g., taking too much pay and too little safety), so the state restricts the contracts they may negotiate.
As defined in Don Boudreaux, Michael Munger, and Russ Roberts on Emergent Order
Other definitions
Policy or parental behavior that overrides a person's choices for their own supposed good.
Robin Hanson on Signalling 05/26/2008
Where it comes up · 3
- Robin Hanson - The Long View and The Elephant in the Brain1 claim
- Chris Blattman on Cash, Poverty, and Development1 claim
- Don Boudreaux, Michael Munger, and Russ Roberts on Emergent Order1 claim
Most important claims · 3 of 3Search all claims for “paternalism” →
- Regulation is sometimes motivated by concern over asymmetric bargaining power and sometimes by paternalism, but historically the big increases in worker safety, shorter work weeks, and higher wages were driven by increased labor productivity rather than by government regulation, casting doubt on the asymmetric-bargaining-power rationale.Don Boudreaux, Michael Munger, and Russ Roberts on Emergent Order
- Paternalism (treating other adults, or one's children, as parents treat children, ostensibly for their own good) is often less about helping and more about being dominant: studies show kids who learn an instrument get no average academic, cognitive, or discipline benefit, so when parents push instruments or bedtimes 'for the child's good,' the real drivers are often the parent's status (bragging, prestige-by-association, child's class advantage) or the parent's own convenience (alone time, avoiding a cranky morning that affects the parent), which parents are reluctant to admit.Robin Hanson - The Long View and The Elephant in the Brain
- Aid workers and programs systematically exaggerate the risk that recipients will misuse cash (on drugs, alcohol, weapons) and exaggerate their own paternalism, which distorts programs; in practice the genuine danger of self-harm or harm to others is rare.Chris Blattman on Cash, Poverty, and Development