overhead ratio
The percentage of a charity's spending that goes to administration, fundraising, and other non-program costs, commonly used by donors as a (flawed) proxy for charity quality.
As defined in Dan Pallotta on Charity and the Culture of the Non-Profit Sector
Where it comes up · 1
Most important claims · 9 of 9Search all claims for “overhead ratio” →
- When the charities, reacting to overhead criticism, dropped Pallotta Teamworks to run the events themselves, their results collapsed: the AIDS Ride beneficiaries saw overhead rise to ~65% and net income fall from $6 million to ~$1.5 million, while Avon's Breast Cancer 3-Days net income dropped from $70.9 million in 2002 to $10 million in 2003—a $60 million loss of unrestricted income in one year.Dan Pallotta on Charity and the Culture of the Non-Profit Sector
- The overhead ratio is deeply flawed because it operates on a mistaken theory of waste (the 90 cents going to the cause may itself be wasted), tells you nothing about service quality (the soup could be rancid), depends entirely on how broadly the charity defines its cause, and offers false transparency since the underlying accounting and definitions are hidden.Dan Pallotta on Charity and the Culture of the Non-Profit Sector
- Charity is a fundamentally broken marketplace because, unlike the cellphone market where buyers can immediately judge an iPhone's quality versus a Samsung's, donors and government grantors choose based on overhead ratios rather than impact—like using the fuel gauge to figure out how fast you are going—so social change is not incentivized; only low overhead spending is.Dan Pallotta on Charity and the Culture of the Non-Profit Sector
- Focusing on costs and overhead eliminates any conversation about impact, so we never ask how effective an organization actually is at solving problems—and a low overhead is meaningless if no problem gets solved while a high overhead is acceptable if the problem does get solved.Dan Pallotta on Charity and the Culture of the Non-Profit Sector
- Demanding that charities keep overhead low prevents them from spending on the overhead things required to grow, institutionalizing the miniaturization of organizations—which is exactly the opposite of what is needed when confronting massive social problems.Dan Pallotta on Charity and the Culture of the Non-Profit Sector
- Pallotta Teamworks was labeled controversial for averaging 40% overhead on the Breast Cancer 3-Days, but given that they fed participants nine meals over three days, erected 4,000 sleeping tents, and ran mobile catering, showering, medical units, and sewage systems moved daily, achieving the events for 40 cents on the dollar was remarkable compared to any vacation industry's margins.Dan Pallotta on Charity and the Culture of the Non-Profit Sector
- Government spending crowds out charitable giving—because people feel they already contribute through taxes and because there is less private money left to give—and government money comes with strings that contaminate it: central officials dictate spending, overhead caps (e.g. 11%) force organizations to steal from other programs, and Europe's heavy government social service correlates with much lower charitable giving.Dan Pallotta on Charity and the Culture of the Non-Profit Sector
- Charities are discouraged from virtually any investment beyond capital investment in buildings—not investing in growth, IT, human resources, or talent because such spending gets labeled overhead—which produces high turnover (especially in development), compounding the losing proposition of asking people to work for two or three times less pay while also depriving them of the resources to realize their potential.Dan Pallotta on Charity and the Culture of the Non-Profit Sector
- Society maintains two separate rule books—one for nonprofits and one for for-profits—and in the name of an ethic this discriminates against the charitable sector across five areas: compensation, advertising/marketing scale, risk-taking, time allowed to demonstrate value, and access to a capital market; this deprivation mindset worked for neighbor-to-neighbor aid but fails for large-scale global problems.Dan Pallotta on Charity and the Culture of the Non-Profit Sector