overdetermined
Caused by more factors than necessary, so that many independent causes each could have produced the outcome.
As defined in Ask Me Anything 16
Where it comes up · 7
- Samo Burja - The Great Founder Theory of History - [Invest Like the Best, EP.339]3 claims
- Ask Me Anything 161 claim
- 283 - Gun Violence In America1 claim
- 300 - A Tale Of Cancellation1 claim
- Ask Me Anything 151 claim
- 117 - Networks Power And Chaos1 claim
- What Really Drives Russia S Foreign Policy From The Ussr To Putin Sergey Radchenko1 claim
Most important claims · 9 of 9Search all claims for “overdetermined” →
- Decisions to invade a country tend to be overdetermined—there are many reasons at once; Czechoslovakia 1968 combined geostrategic fear of losing a platform, fear of ideological contagion from reform, and the need to assert superpower credibility, and Putin's Ukraine decision similarly combined geostrategic NATO fears, imperialist thinking that Ukraine is part of Russia, and a desire to make an example to deter others.What Really Drives Russia S Foreign Policy From The Ussr To Putin Sergey Radchenko
- Human violence has several distinct sources — true psychopaths who differ from normal people, ordinary people who do horrible things because of their beliefs, people caught in cycles of vendetta, and the frankly mentally ill/delusional — and these can overlap so that an act of violence is overdetermined by multiple causes.300 - A Tale Of Cancellation
- Quantum indeterminacy is a red herring for free will: if rolling dice (quantum or otherwise) changes your behavior, that is not a demonstration of free will, and at the gross scale human behavior is so massively overdetermined that you would do the same thing a thousand times in a row—you didn't invent yourself or determine your own preferences, so even where outcomes could differ you are not their author.Ask Me Anything 15
- Napoleon is not clearly a great founder, since his military reforms were likely overdetermined and his industrial legacy was short-lived, though his civil code plausibly marked Europe's departure from feudalism.Samo Burja - The Great Founder Theory of History - [Invest Like the Best, EP.339]
- The 2016 election result was overdetermined—any of three to thirty different factors (the Comey letter, the DNC email hack, ISIS attacks on US soil, Clinton's failure to campaign in swing states, her being a weak candidate) being different could have flipped a margin of only 39,000 votes—so single-variable counterfactuals that change only what suits the analyst's predilections are methodologically unsound.117 - Networks Power And Chaos
- Trump's election was overdetermined by multiple causes, including how poorly Hillary Clinton was trusted as a candidate and, importantly, the fact that millions of Americans feel left out of the global digital economy driven by information technology, globalization, trade, outsourcing, automation, and immigration; this understandable dissatisfaction organized into a protest vote to 'burn it all down' by people who feel they no longer have skin in the game.Ask Me Anything 16
- Some knowledge, such as calculus discovered independently by Newton, Leibniz, and Japanese mathematicians, is overdetermined and will be discovered in parallel, but the specific organizations that transmit and cohere that knowledge into a particular institution are not overdetermined.Samo Burja - The Great Founder Theory of History - [Invest Like the Best, EP.339]
- Mass shootings arise from at least three highly non-analogous sources that can overlap and overdetermine an event: frank mental illness (the deranged, inarticulate shooter like Adam Lanza), comparatively normal people gripped by a dangerous ideology (e.g., jihadists or white supremacists who would show no diagnosable illness), and morally insane psychopaths who are not delusional and may even be charming on first meeting—each requiring a different societal response.283 - Gun Violence In America
- Napoleon's military reforms, including the general staff system, were somewhat influential but overdetermined, meaning they would likely have developed in the same direction even without him.Samo Burja - The Great Founder Theory of History - [Invest Like the Best, EP.339]