open air prison
A metaphor describing Gaza as a confined territory whose residents cannot leave and whose flow of goods Israel controls, debated by Roberts as partly propaganda.
As defined in A Lively Debate on the Israeli-Palestinian Conflict (with Robert Wright)
Other definitions
A characterization of a enclosed or controlled territory where residents are confined through military or political control, with restricted movement and resources, though not formally incarcerated; used to describe Gaza under Israeli management.
Why Israel is in deep trouble | John Mearsheimer with Tom Switzer
Where it comes up · 3
- A Lively Debate on the Israeli-Palestinian Conflict (with Robert Wright)1 claim
- Why Israel is in deep trouble | John Mearsheimer with Tom Switzer1 claim
- Mohammed El1 claim
Most important claims · 3 of 3Search all claims for “open air prison” →
- Before October 7th, Gaza was a giant open-air prison created when Israel withdrew settlers in 2005 under Ariel Sharon because Gaza was a 'hornet's nest' and Israel wanted to focus on the West Bank. Netanyahu was satisfied managing this situation and actually funded and supported Hamas because Netanyahu opposed a two-state solution while Mahmoud Abbas (Palestinian Authority) favored it, so Netanyahu played Hamas against Abbas.Why Israel is in deep trouble | John Mearsheimer with Tom Switzer
- The 'open air prison' description of Gaza is partly a propaganda line because before October 7th much of Gaza had beautiful parks, villas, beachfront, restaurants and car dealerships rather than being a uniform slum; Hamas diverted enormous resources into building tunnels, so where Gaza failed to flourish Roberts blames Hamas more than Israel's blockade.A Lively Debate on the Israeli-Palestinian Conflict (with Robert Wright)
- The framing of Hamas firing rockets as unprovoked is false; the provocation is that Gazans are forced to live in a densely populated, UN-deemed uninhabitable open-air prison without clean water, imports, or freedom of movement, so the rockets are retaliation for the ongoing siege.Mohammed El