open access order
A social order (per North, Wallis, Weingast) in which everyone has some access to economic opportunity and political rights, including the right to form organizations to compete against incumbents.
As defined in Lee Ohanian, Arnold Kling, and John Cochrane on the Future of Freedom, Democracy, and Prosperity
Where it comes up · 2
- Barry Weingast on Violence, Power and a Theory of Nearly Everything 8/13/20078 claims
- Lee Ohanian, Arnold Kling, and John Cochrane on the Future of Freedom, Democracy, and Prosperity3 claims
Most important claims · 10 of 11Search all claims for “open access order” →
- There are three types of societies ('orders'): the primitive order (small hunter-gatherer bands of 25-200 with little specialization or wealth accumulation), the limited access order or 'natural state' which solves violence through limited access, and the open access order.Barry Weingast on Violence, Power and a Theory of Nearly Everything 8/13/2007
- Limited access orders fail to grow as fast as open access orders because limited access makes it hard for anyone to form organizations, restricting competition and entrepreneurial power and embedding monopoly rents throughout the system.Barry Weingast on Violence, Power and a Theory of Nearly Everything 8/13/2007
- All organizations and special interests seek privileges and rents in every society including open access ones; the crucial difference is that in open access orders with many competing organizations, granting privileges to a few denies the rest, so excluded groups block special deals (e.g., three transcontinental railroad routes blocking each other before the Civil War) and creating new markets remains unrestricted.Barry Weingast on Violence, Power and a Theory of Nearly Everything 8/13/2007
- Open access orders rest on three pillars: open access to organizations of all types (economic, political, social, religious), rule-of-law institutions and constitutions, and shared beliefs of inclusion and equality before the law.Barry Weingast on Violence, Power and a Theory of Nearly Everything 8/13/2007
- Natural states progress through stages distinguished by their organizations: fragile (only the state organization, prone to collapse—Chad, Somalia, Rwanda, Afghanistan), basic (differentiated organizations but all part of the state), and mature (private but elite-based organizations with privilege); effective development helps a country move along this progression rather than leap to open access.Barry Weingast on Violence, Power and a Theory of Nearly Everything 8/13/2007
- Limited access orders have per capita incomes roughly between $400 and $8,000-$10,000, with the richest (Mexico, Argentina, Brazil, Russia) at the upper limit; open access orders are above $20,000, creating a large hard-to-bridge gap, with a few transition societies like South Korea in between.Barry Weingast on Violence, Power and a Theory of Nearly Everything 8/13/2007
- The 'tragic brilliance' mechanism distinguishes elections in limited access orders: in open access orders certain goods (water, electricity) are provided to citizens regardless of how they vote, but in Mexico under the PRI, ~80% of local government budgets came from higher governments conditional on the locality voting for the PRI, so they could literally cut your water off for not voting correctly.Barry Weingast on Violence, Power and a Theory of Nearly Everything 8/13/2007
- Open access to organizations underpins not only economic competition but a rich civil society—soccer leagues, churches, interest groups, book clubs—and this richness of civil society is a defining feature of open access orders and is suppressed in limited access orders because regimes find people associating to be dangerous.Barry Weingast on Violence, Power and a Theory of Nearly Everything 8/13/2007
- Following North, Wallis, and Weingast, societies are either limited access orders—where a ruling coalition holds all political rights and economic opportunity, stays stable by collecting monopoly rents while everyone else is powerless—or open access orders, where everyone has some access to economic opportunity and political rights; a key test is whether anyone can form an organization to compete against incumbent political or economic interests, which is forbidden in limited access orders and open to all in open access orders.Lee Ohanian, Arnold Kling, and John Cochrane on the Future of Freedom, Democracy, and Prosperity
- Open access orders tend to remain stable and are hard to destabilize because, by definition, everyone has a stake in the system, and reaching such an order requires building up layers of individual norms, cultural beliefs, and formal institutions—where documents like Magna Carta matter not for what they did in 1200 but for the cultural reverence they generate centuries later—so one must be brave to forecast that such an order will degenerate.Lee Ohanian, Arnold Kling, and John Cochrane on the Future of Freedom, Democracy, and Prosperity