non-ideal theory
The branch of Rawls's work dealing with justice under non-ideal, partially-compliant real-world conditions, as opposed to ideal theory's perfectly just society.
As defined in 121 | Cornel West on What Democracy Is and Should Be
Where it comes up · 2
- 121 | Cornel West on What Democracy Is and Should Be2 claims
- 139 | Elizabeth Anderson on Equality, Work, and Ideology1 claim
Most important claims · 3 of 3Search all claims for “non-ideal theory” →
- John Rawls's 1971 theory of justice was predicated on consensus and agreement 'in the metropole' while ignoring hundreds of US military interventions abroad—a disassociation of foreign from domestic policy—and rested on disproportionate corporate and professional influence, so the suffering it overlooked (empire abroad, race and class at home) comes back to haunt the system.121 | Cornel West on What Democracy Is and Should Be
- Rawls's theory of justice was grounded in a deeply tragic, Hobbesian sensibility born of his experience of mass suffering in World War II and personal loss, which is why he revered Lincoln as a figure who sustained rational democratic experimentation amid massive hatred and division.121 | Cornel West on What Democracy Is and Should Be
- Aiming political philosophy at an ideal society is unreliable because we cannot know what the relevant normative categories will be in the future, ideal theory tends to paper over present structural injustices, and moral inquiry may never converge on a fixed ideal—so we should start from current problems and treat our ideals as error-prone, revising them by living through them.139 | Elizabeth Anderson on Equality, Work, and Ideology