neurophysiology
The biological functioning of the nervous system and brain that, on Harris's account, gives rise to thoughts and actions outside conscious control.
As defined in 241 - Final Thoughts On Free Will
Where it comes up · 4
- Ask Sam Harris Anything #23 claims
- 241 - Final Thoughts On Free Will2 claims
- 39 - Free Will Revisited2 claims
- 105 - Richard Dawkins Sam Harris And Matt Dillahunty1 claim
Most important claims · 8 of 8Search all claims for “neurophysiology” →
- A complete understanding of neurophysiology, should we ever attain it, would be exculpatory in the same sense as Charles Whitman's brain tumor: it is 'brain tumors all the way down,' because if we fully understood the charge on the synapse that led someone to hit send on an email, that charge is the tiniest brain tumor ever found, something the agent did not author, making it the real reason for the action.39 - Free Will Revisited
- Claims about spiritual experience (e.g., bliss during prayer, peace from meditation) can be studied scientifically as claims about experience itself, but claims about what these experiences mean for reality (e.g., that they prove God's grace or divine attention) are metaphysical claims about non-existent entities and are not amenable to scientific justification.Ask Sam Harris Anything #2
- Thought experiments with memory (recalling someone from your social network) demonstrate that we do not consciously author our thoughts; the person who comes to mind feels chosen, but we cannot account for why that person rather than another appeared, proving that mind selects thoughts outside of consciousness.Ask Sam Harris Anything #2
- Charles Whitman, who murdered 16 people in 1966, left a note describing inexplicable violent impulses and was found at autopsy to have a tumor pressing on his amygdala that could have caused them; learning this shifts our moral intuitions toward seeing him as an unlucky victim of biology, and Harris argues this is just a special case—if we fully understood any murderer's neurophysiology, genes, and life history, it would be equally exculpatory and the basis for deep blame would disappear.241 - Final Thoughts On Free Will
- Even the freest possible choice—picking any film with unlimited time—reveals no free will, because the films that occur to you arise from neurophysiology you cannot inspect (your 'Wizard of Oz circuits' were not in play), and rewinding the brain and adding back any randomness would yield the same choice again and again, so neither determinism nor randomness leaves room for a freely choosing subject.241 - Final Thoughts On Free Will
- Attempting to articulate a libertarian free will that is compatible with determinism by saying 'we can change subsequent events' fails because the 'we' that changes events is itself just more neural events arising from prior causes—there is no escape from the causal chain through which a conscious self could intervene from outside.Ask Sam Harris Anything #2
- If a future brain-scanning technique could know everything you were going to think and do before you consciously could — confronting you with a pre-cognitive transcript of your own behavior moment after moment — it would fundamentally undermine people's felt sense of being agents and authors of their actions; Harris argues this is in fact a neurological reality, since you are not the first to know what you're about to think and do.39 - Free Will Revisited
- If consciousness simply is its neurophysiology, then it is effective only in virtue of that neurophysiology, so the subjective experiential side—the most important thing in anyone's life—may not be what is behaviorally effective, deepening the puzzle of why consciousness would be selected for.105 - Richard Dawkins Sam Harris And Matt Dillahunty