near-death experience
A now-common term (abbreviated NDE) for the strikingly similar experiences reported by people close to death, such as hovering above the body or seeing the dead.
As defined in Facing Death (with Sebastian Junger)
Where it comes up · 6
- 369 - Escaping Death4 claims
- Ross Douthat on Trump, Mysticism and Psychedelics | The Ezra Klein Show4 claims
- Rational and Religious (with Ross Douthat)3 claims
- Facing Death (with Sebastian Junger)2 claims
- 227 - Knowing The Mind1 claim
- Lessons from 1,000+ YC startups: Resilience, tar pit ideas, pivoting, more | Dalton Caldwell (YC)1 claim
Most important claims · 10 of 15Search all claims for “near-death experience” →
- From the skeptic's side, none of the people reporting near-death experiences actually experienced irreversible brain death—they had residual brain activity or restartable hearts—so however interesting, NDE reports are correlated with ongoing brain activity and cannot tell us what happens after death.369 - Escaping Death
- Hospice 'near near-death' visions of dead relatives can be explained as an evolved capacity to smooth the passage of death, but full near-death experiences in people who would historically have simply died (e.g., killed by a saber-toothed tiger) lack any plausible evolutionary adaptation, since there was no survival benefit to a dying person seeing a white light they would never report to their tribe.Rational and Religious (with Ross Douthat)
- A large percentage of near-death experiences feature the dying person feeling they are hovering above their loved ones or hospital bed, unable to be seen or heard—a pattern that disturbingly matched a vivid dream Junger had 36 hours before nearly dying.369 - Escaping Death
- The evidence from near-death experiences may suffer from selection bias—people with jumbly, awful experiences may simply not talk about them as much—and the consistent imagery of tunnels, light, and welcoming dead relatives may be culturally seeded and hallucinated from prior exposure to the trope.Rational and Religious (with Ross Douthat)
- Modern medicine has resuscitated far more people from the brink of death than ever before in history, and a materialist would predict their experiences to be chaotic, dreamlike, dream-logic jumbles that are unmemorable; instead we get strikingly consistent cross-cultural patterns (dead relatives, life review, tunnel, white light, intense reality, life-changing effects), which counts as a point in religion's favor.Rational and Religious (with Ross Douthat)
- The subject-object collapse and pure experience described in meditation and psychedelics is also reported by people who survived coma or life-threatening conditions and had near-death experiences, a once-taboo subject the Coma Science Group has studied for ten years with nearly 2,000 testimonies, comparing these to other altered states.227 - Knowing The Mind
- Spiritual experiences show patterns and consistency across cultures and contexts—near-death experiences, miraculous healings, encounters with divine beings—which suggests an underlying structure rather than random brain misfirings.Ross Douthat on Trump, Mysticism and Psychedelics | The Ezra Klein Show
- Unlike a room of people given LSD who all hallucinate different things, dying people consistently see dead people—and sometimes people they didn't know had recently died—a cross-cultural consistency that the neurochemical explanation does not fully account for and that leaves a genuine crack of mystery.369 - Escaping Death
- Near-death experiences are not fragmentary, dreamlike, or chaotic but are described as extraordinarily real, intensely detailed, emotionally coherent, and causally efficacious in changing people's lives—making the evolutionary just-so story of random brain misfires implausible.Ross Douthat on Trump, Mysticism and Psychedelics | The Ezra Klein Show
- While neurological processes (low blood oxygen, stress on the dying brain, G-forces in a centrifuge) can reproduce out-of-body and hovering experiences, what cannot be explained is that dying people don't see random things like fire trucks or flamingos—they all specifically see the dead, sometimes people they didn't know had died, which is not probative but arouses serious questions for a rationalist.Facing Death (with Sebastian Junger)