naturalness
The expectation that dimensionless parameters in a theory should be of order one, with small or large values requiring explanation.
As defined in AMA | November 2025
Other definitions
The principle that the parameters of a fundamental theory should not require extreme fine-tuning, so new physics expected at a given scale should appear near it.
370 | Daniel Akerib on a Faint Hint of Dark Matter
Where it comes up · 13
- AMA | February 20233 claims
- 359 | Solo: Theories of Dark Energy2 claims
- 370 | Daniel Akerib on a Faint Hint of Dark Matter2 claims
- Ep. 31 - Aging And The Awakening1 claim
- 245 | Solo: The Crisis in Physics1 claim
- 31 | Brian Greene on the Multiverse, Inflation, and the String Theory Landscape1 claim
- 321 | David Tong on Open Questions in Quantum Field Theory1 claim
- 358 | Solo: Vacuum Energy and the Cosmological Constant1 claim
and 5 more
Most important claims · 10 of 17Search all claims for “naturalness” →
- Calling the universe preposterous (as in the discovery of a non-zero cosmological constant) is not insulting the universe, which by definition cannot be unnatural; it is naming ourselves, reflecting the mismatch between our theoretical expectations (e.g. naturalness arguments that the cosmological constant should be zero) and what experiments reveal, reminding us we are not done understanding it.AMA | May 2021
- The absence of new physics beyond the Higgs at the LHC is shocking because aesthetic arguments about naturalness predicted something new should appear at that scale; but the standard model alone could explain observations, and physicists must be careful not to impose human mathematical and aesthetic sensibilities on how the world actually works.31 | Brian Greene on the Multiverse, Inflation, and the String Theory Landscape
- When a feature of the universe (like dark energy's coincidence problem, the cosmological constant problem, the hierarchy problem, or inflation) seems unnatural or preposterous, it is never a criticism of the universe but a reminder that our expectations—set by some subset of what we observe—are wrong, signaling something we don't yet understand.AMA | February 2023
- When physics has strong experimental guidance, wrong ideas get shot down quickly, so you can reach correct ideas even with sloppy reasoning because nature guides you kicking and screaming; but for questions with meager empirical guidance—like why the cosmological constant or Higgs mass are small—the old fast ways of thinking aren't enough and you must think more carefully, asking why you assumed a number was natural in the first place.Holiday Message 2022: Thinking Really Slowly
- Inflationary models are not strongly contingent on supersymmetry; while the inflaton potential must be fine-tuned (shallow slope, ~60 e-folds), supersymmetry can be broken at a high scale and still help, so the failure to find supersymmetry at the LHC affects the hierarchy problem (which needs SUSY broken near the electroweak scale) but not inflation.AMA | February 2023
- In foundational areas like cosmology, quantum gravity, naturalness, anthropic reasoning, the arrow of time, locality, and quantum foundations, philosophers understand the problems at least as well as physicists and are much better at diagnosing them, while physicists are good at ignoring problems unless forced to confront them; collaboration at these intersections would be valuable but rarely happens.Holiday Message 2021 | On Disciplines & Cocktails
- A naturalness problem arises when a theory contains a dimensionless number that is extremely tiny (or huge) for no good reason, when it should be of order unity; the hierarchy problem is the ~10^-15 ratio of the electroweak scale to the Planck scale, with no reason quantum corrections shouldn't push the electroweak scale up to the Planck scale, and the cosmological constant problem is the analogous ~10^-30 (or 10^-120 in energy density) discrepancy for vacuum energy.245 | Solo: The Crisis in Physics
- In the 1990s supersymmetry seemed a natural explanation whose dark matter would sit at a natural mass and scattering scale, and after searching seven or eight orders of magnitude without success, the field began asking whether nature chose something else.370 | Daniel Akerib on a Faint Hint of Dark Matter
- The naturalness argument (hierarchy problem) led most of the community, including Tong, to expect the LHC would find new particles accompanying the Higgs boson as a portal to the next layer of reality, but despite the LHC working beyond expectations and finding the Higgs, those particles are not there—so nature is telling us the well-motivated naturalness argument is wrong and the hierarchy problem has no solution.321 | David Tong on Open Questions in Quantum Field Theory
- Physicists' surprise at constant values rests on a 'naturalness' prior in which dimensionless ratios are expected to fall in an order-one range relative to fundamental scales like the Planck mass, so a value like M/10^120 is judged surprising and fine-tuned, while M is judged natural—an assumption a non-physicist would not hold without that prior.AMA | November 2025