my-side bias
Mercier and Sperber's term for the bias toward favoring arguments that support one's own position.
As defined in Ian Leslie on Conflicted
Where it comes up · 2
- Steven Pinker Meets Richard Dawkins | On Reason and Rationality4 claims
- Ian Leslie on Conflicted1 claim
Most important claims · 5 of 5Search all claims for “my-side bias” →
- My-side bias—the tendency to believe claims that are politically congenial rather than what is supported by evidence—is one of the most robust of approximately 200 documented cognitive fallacies, and unlike most other fallacies, high intelligence and numeracy provide no protection against it.Steven Pinker Meets Richard Dawkins | On Reason and Rationality
- Mercier and Sperber argue our biases are only flaws at the individual level; once thinking is understood as collaborative, confirmation bias contributes to group intelligence, because when each person makes their best case and tries to knock out others' arguments, a Darwinian process of generation, variation, and selection weeds out weak arguments and the most robust survive.Ian Leslie on Conflicted
- Internet and social media expose people to more diversity of viewpoints than the pre-internet era when newspapers were one-sided, yet the my-side bias persists—suggesting that mere exposure to opposing views is insufficient to overcome motivated reasoning.Steven Pinker Meets Richard Dawkins | On Reason and Rationality
- Sociologist Keith Stanovich's book 'The Bias That Divides Us' demonstrates that my-side bias is equally powerful among left-wingers and right-wingers, making it a bipartisan cognitive phenomenon rather than a partisan political strategy.Steven Pinker Meets Richard Dawkins | On Reason and Rationality
- My-side bias was not the default state but is a persistent threat; rationality requires continuous defense of institutions like a responsible free press, government record-keeping, and science, since there is always danger of backsliding into conspiracy theories and demonization.Steven Pinker Meets Richard Dawkins | On Reason and Rationality