mutual assured destruction
The doctrine that two nuclear-armed sides are deterred from war because any attack would guarantee the destruction of both.
As defined in Annie Jacobsen
Where it comes up · 6
- John Mearsheimer2 claims
- Annie Jacobsen1 claim
- 186 - The Bomb1 claim
- Special Episode Engineering The Apocalypse1 claim
- Annie Jacobsen1 claim
- AMA | November 20241 claim
Most important claims · 7 of 7Search all claims for “mutual assured destruction” →
- The doctrine of mutual assured destruction relies on no one launching, but the whole philosophy falls apart the moment the first launch occurs—leaving the president six minutes to choose between killing everyone on earth in retaliation or absorbing the strike, with no good option.Annie Jacobsen
- U.S. nuclear weapons have always been aimed primarily at military targets, not adversary cities; McNamara's concept of 'assured destruction' (a critic added the 'mutual' to coin 'MAD') was a budgetary and political device to dampen the Air Force's appetite for more missiles, with only about 200 of thousands of weapons aimed at urban-industrial targets, and even McNamara told presidents in secret memos this was not how the weapons would actually be used.186 - The Bomb
- Because cheap offensive drones and missiles cost far less to deploy than the defenses required to stop them (an Iranian attack costing ~$80 million versus over $1 billion to defend against), improving and cheapening drone capabilities may produce a conventional analog of nuclear mutual assured destruction in which there is no practical defense.AMA | November 2024
- In a mutual-assured-destruction world, nuclear weapons are used not against military targets but for manipulation of risk and demonstration effect—using a handful of weapons, possibly in a remote area, to throw both sides onto the slippery slope toward Armageddon and create powerful incentives for everyone to end the conflict immediately.John Mearsheimer
- The alternative to nuclear weapons is not peace but other deterrents like biological, chemical, or AI weapons; since we have 75+ years of experience managing nuclear weapons, switching to mutual assured destruction via biological weapons would not be safer.Annie Jacobsen
- Because Ukraine has no nuclear weapons to retaliate, it is not a mutual-assured-destruction situation, so the Russians are more likely to believe they can get away with using nuclear weapons in Ukraine than against NATO; if Russia did so and the West retaliated conventionally (per Petraeus's recommendation), it would produce a great-power war between NATO and Russia with unknowable escalation dynamics.John Mearsheimer
- Although a vial of obliterating contagion has its own mad-style deterrence built in (the unleasher likely dies too), this won't deter everyone, because suicidal mass murderers like the Las Vegas shooter are committed to self-annihilation and thus undeterrable by nature—so unlike the stable, decades-vetted heads of state we trusted with nukes, we cannot count on deterrence working against those who toss the bio dice.Special Episode Engineering The Apocalypse