moral credibility
The reputation a legal system earns for reliably tracking what people see as just, which gives it social authority to influence behavior beyond coercion.
As defined in Paul Robinson on Cooperation, Punishment and the Criminal Justice System
Where it comes up · 1
Most important claims · 5 of 5Search all claims for “moral credibility” →
- Psych lab studies show that nudging subjects toward disillusionment with the criminal justice system—by exposing them to cases where it badly erred—measurably reduces their willingness to comply, report crimes, serve as witnesses, and internalize new norms, with dose-response evidence (three levels of disillusionment producing three levels of compliance), demonstrating that a system's moral reputation drives crime-control effectiveness.Paul Robinson on Cooperation, Punishment and the Criminal Justice System
- During American Prohibition, crime rates rose generally—even for offenses unrelated to alcohol—because widespread, openly tolerated violation of a law people did not see as condemnable undermined the criminal law's moral reputation, and that reduced reputation translated into reduced compliance across other areas until repeal began restoring it.Paul Robinson on Cooperation, Punishment and the Criminal Justice System
- Optimal-deterrence theory recommends raising punishments when the probability of being caught is low, but this is inherently unfair because those who are caught bear a penalty disproportionate to their blameworthiness; punishing more than is deserved carries a hidden cost of undermining the system's moral credibility, which itself reduces crime-control effectiveness.Paul Robinson on Cooperation, Punishment and the Criminal Justice System
- The criminal justice system is in a credibility competition where every contact between a police officer and a citizen is an opportunity to either build the system's reputation and moral influence or damage it through disrespect and arbitrariness; recognizing this should drive improvements in police selection, training, and culture that make the system more effective.Paul Robinson on Cooperation, Punishment and the Criminal Justice System
- Because Soviet criminal law had a very bad reputation as a moral authority and was effective only through police-state coercion, the collapse of the Soviet Union produced a significant crime problem, whereas societies whose criminal law enjoys high moral reputation need little coercive police apparatus to secure compliance.Paul Robinson on Cooperation, Punishment and the Criminal Justice System