modified gravity
An alternative to dark matter that proposes changing the laws of gravity themselves rather than adding unseen matter to explain galactic and cosmic observations.
As defined in 240 | Andrew Pontzen on Simulations and the Universe
Where it comes up · 4
- 245 | Solo: The Crisis in Physics6 claims
- 240 | Andrew Pontzen on Simulations and the Universe3 claims
- 359 | Solo: Theories of Dark Energy1 claim
- AMA | July 20211 claim
Most important claims · 10 of 11Search all claims for “modified gravity” →
- The choice to work on dark matter rather than modified gravity is a pragmatic allocation of finite scientific resources and time toward the more promising line of inquiry, not a declaration that dark matter is right and modified gravity wrong—since neither can be certain until dark matter is found in the lab.240 | Andrew Pontzen on Simulations and the Universe
- It is perfectly natural for a field theory to be modified at small distances and high energies but very unnatural to modify it at long distances and low energies; new effects relevant for galaxies but invisible in the solar system are hard to construct, giving theoretical strikes against modifying gravity to replace dark matter.245 | Solo: The Crisis in Physics
- When someone claims to replace dark matter with modified gravity by talking about spiral galaxy rotation curves, you can stop listening, because the best evidence for dark matter is no longer galaxies and clusters but the cosmic microwave background, whose pattern of acoustic peaks provides quantitatively superior, predicted-in-advance evidence for dark matter specifically.245 | Solo: The Crisis in Physics
- Most simulators work within the dark matter paradigm rather than modified gravity because dark matter has been remarkably predictive—the specific ripples in the CMB and the way structure grows were predictions of the dark matter hypothesis—whereas modified gravity has only tried to explain existing observations and has never made an accurate prediction, making it less attractive to work on despite not being proven wrong.240 | Andrew Pontzen on Simulations and the Universe
- In the Bullet Cluster, two galaxy clusters passed through each other so the hot intergalactic gas (most of the ordinary matter) collided and got stuck while the galaxies passed through; gravitational lensing shows the gravity is located where the galaxies are, not where the bulk of ordinary matter (gas) is, which is naturally explained by collisionless dark matter passing through, contradicting modified gravity's prediction.245 | Solo: The Crisis in Physics
- Dark matter definitively exists; even if gravity is also modified on cosmological scales, the data require some new source of gravity beyond ordinary matter, because effective field theory says it is very hard to modify gravity at long distances without affecting other experiments, and the observational evidence is decisive.245 | Solo: The Crisis in Physics
- Modified gravity theories that successfully fit the CMB, like Bekenstein's TeVeS, do so only by adding new fields (vector and scalar degrees of freedom) that carry energy and create a gravitational field independent of ordinary matter; that is, by definition, dark matter — so calling it modified gravity is just a labeling choice that produces a weird, broken, hard-to-understand version of dark matter.245 | Solo: The Crisis in Physics
- A criticism of the modified gravity community is that they tend to focus on particular observations they can explain rather than the full gamut of available data, and even within galaxies there are many observations modified gravity struggles to explain—though focusing one's work is itself sometimes necessary.240 | Andrew Pontzen on Simulations and the Universe
- Dark matter and dark energy have not been directly detected and are inferred from spacetime behavior, so they could in principle be artifacts of modifying gravity on cosmological scales, though MOND is now ruled out by cosmic microwave background data.359 | Solo: Theories of Dark Energy
- There is a legitimate reason people pursue modified gravity: MOND predicts a real, observed relationship between ordinary matter and dark matter in spiral galaxies (a characteristic radius inside which dark matter is not needed) that is not directly explained by the dark matter hypothesis; however, the difficulty of explaining a feature is far weaker than modified gravity's fatal problem of being ruled out by data.245 | Solo: The Crisis in Physics