mixed state
A quantum state described by a probability distribution over pure states, used when full information is unavailable, as for an entangled subsystem.
As defined in AMA | September 2021
Where it comes up · 5
- 218 | Raphael Bousso on Black Holes and the Holographic Universe2 claims
- AMA | December 20202 claims
- 253 | David Deutsch on Science, Complexity, and Explanation1 claim
- AMA | September 20211 claim
- Mindscape Ask Me Anything, Sean Carroll | July 20261 claim
Most important claims · 7 of 7Search all claims for “mixed state” →
- There are different kinds of entropy: the coarse-grained Boltzmann entropy (counting microstates in a macrostate) that was low at the Big Bang and grows, and the von Neumann or entanglement entropy in quantum mechanics, where two entangled subsystems have no individual wave function and are each automatically in a mixed state with an associated entropy even when the composite system's exact state is known.AMA | September 2021
- Hawking's calculation does not merely show a black-body spectrum and infer no information; it specifically predicts the outgoing radiation is in a thermal density matrix, a mixed state characterized by having a black-body spectrum and no other information, which is why physicists doubt it is the final answer if information escapes, requiring secret correlations that preserve the spectrum without being exactly thermal.AMA | December 2020
- Information is expected to be conserved because unitary Schrodinger evolution conserves it; black holes appearing to turn pure states into mixed states would violate this, and indirect evidence including the loss of energy conservation and quantum coherence when information conservation is dropped, plus the AdS/CFT correspondence where the gravity-free dual theory conserves information, supports believing information is conserved.AMA | December 2020
- Argues that a mixed state is merely a probabilistic description available to observers within individual branches, and so loses meaning when applied to the global quantum state of the multiverse, where all microscopic information is tracked.Mindscape Ask Me Anything, Sean Carroll | July 2026
- Jeff Pennington, Netta Engelhardt and collaborators recently and independently discovered how to derive the Page curve using just gravity—by sewing together multiple copies of the spacetime—showing the entropy of Hawking radiation rises and then falls back to one, providing the first direct gravity calculation confirming that information is not lost in black holes.218 | Raphael Bousso on Black Holes and the Holographic Universe
- Quantum theory is false (not merely approximate) because it conflicts with general relativity: quantum mechanics says the sun is in a superposition of many positions, some far from where we see it (amplified by chaotic interactions), yet neither theory tells us how the sun's gravitational effect differs across these branches—so we lack the right equations, and both theories are at best excellent approximations.253 | David Deutsch on Science, Complexity, and Explanation
- Hawking initially calculated that a black hole formed from a definite state radiates into a mixed state of many possibilities, meaning the information about the initial state is lost—you always get the same garbage out no matter what you put in—which is the core of the nearly 50-year black hole information loss debate.218 | Raphael Bousso on Black Holes and the Holographic Universe