metric fixation
The combined practice of replacing judgment with standardized measurement, attaching rewards and punishments to those measures, and publicizing them for accountability.
As defined in Jerry Muller on the Tyranny of Metrics
Where it comes up · 1
Most important claims · 5 of 5Search all claims for “metric fixation” →
- The fact that an institution is not working well does not mean that imposing metric fixation will improve it; a problematic situation does not validate the proposed solution, and in many cases metric fixation actually makes the situation worse, so skepticism should focus on the efficacy of the remedy rather than denying the problem.Jerry Muller on the Tyranny of Metrics
- When metric fixation is imposed on schools and non-profits in the name of 'running like a business,' they don't actually run like a real business but like a simplified caricature of one, ignoring that real businesses depend on intrinsic motivation and unmeasurable qualities like mentoring and cooperation, and that non-profits have a multiplicity of purposes rather than a single bottom line.Jerry Muller on the Tyranny of Metrics
- The tyranny of metrics is a pattern combining three individually plausible beliefs—that standardized numerical measurement should replace fallible human judgment, that people are best motivated by attaching rewards and penalties to measured performance, and that accountability is achieved by publishing those standardized measures—which in combination turn out to be counterproductive.Jerry Muller on the Tyranny of Metrics
- Paradoxically, metric fixation can reduce accountability: a system that lets politicians, police, and residents all rally around a falsified cheerleading metric (e.g., a claimed 5% crime reduction) actually obscures the real situation, so the very tool intended to create accountability undermines it.Jerry Muller on the Tyranny of Metrics
- No Child Left Behind's regime of testing, publicizing results, and rewarding/punishing schools had absolutely no effect on the achievement gap between white and black/Hispanic students, but it did narrow the range and depth of subjects taught as teaching was reoriented toward maximizing test scores.Jerry Muller on the Tyranny of Metrics