mentalizing
Abstractly thinking about and reasoning over another person's thoughts, intentions, and feelings; associated with the cognitive form of empathy called sympathy.
As defined in 23 | Lisa Aziz-Zadeh on Embodied Cognition, Mirror Neurons, and Empathy
Other definitions
The cognitive process of inferring what another person thinks, believes, or intends; Camerer prefers this term to theory of mind.
373 | Colin Camerer on the Neuroscience of Economic Thinking
Where it comes up · 6
- 373 | Colin Camerer on the Neuroscience of Economic Thinking3 claims
- Steven Pinker on Common Knowledge2 claims
- 23 | Lisa Aziz-Zadeh on Embodied Cognition, Mirror Neurons, and Empathy2 claims
- Joseph Henrich1 claim
- 478 - The Psychedelic Mind1 claim
- Marissa King - The Science of Social Networks - [Invest Like the Best, EP. 217]1 claim
Most important claims · 10 of 10Search all claims for “mentalizing” →
- Researchers isolate the mentalizing circuit by showing participants 'how' versus 'why' pictures matched for visual content and button presses, then subtracting 'how' activity from 'why' activity, which reveals right temporoparietal junction and dorsomedial prefrontal cortex as key regions.373 | Colin Camerer on the Neuroscience of Economic Thinking
- A woman born without arms and legs still tries to use her motor representations to understand others' actions, but for actions impossible for her (like tip-toeing or using scissors) she additionally recruits sympathy/mentalizing regions—showing the brain offloads to abstract understanding when embodied simulation cannot apply.23 | Lisa Aziz-Zadeh on Embodied Cognition, Mirror Neurons, and Empathy
- Humans cannot hold an infinite recursion of 'I-know-that-she-knows' in a finite skull; instead, common knowledge is psychologically realized as a sense that something is public, salient, self-evident, or 'out there'—and when two people observe something while observing each other observing it, that mutual visibility is enough to guarantee common knowledge.Steven Pinker on Common Knowledge
- Dunbar's number of about 150 reflects biological and evolutionary constraints on how many people an individual can maintain, driven by the capacity of the brain to mentalize, and the same figure governs the size of organizational units.Marissa King - The Science of Social Networks - [Invest Like the Best, EP. 217]
- Camerer prefers 'mentalizing' to 'theory of mind' because it describes the process of constructing a representation of another person's mind, and the neural mentalizing circuit centers on right temporoparietal junction, dorsomedial prefrontal cortex, and posterior cingulate.373 | Colin Camerer on the Neuroscience of Economic Thinking
- Fiction—especially mysteries with complex plots—exists because, like any survival-relevant talent, we enjoy practicing the skill of getting inside other people's heads (and inside the head of someone trying to get inside another's head), with play serving as rehearsal that perfects the underlying ability.Steven Pinker on Common Knowledge
- Psychologists divide empathy into three components served by three different brain networks: sympathy/mentalizing (abstractly understanding another's feelings, located in prefrontal cortex, temporoparietal junction, and precuneus), affect sharing/empathy proper (literally feeling another's feelings, located in emotion and mirror regions), and compassion (proactive warmth and desire to help)—and these can dissociate, as psychopaths excel at abstract sympathy but lack affect sharing while people with autism show the reverse pattern.23 | Lisa Aziz-Zadeh on Embodied Cognition, Mirror Neurons, and Empathy
- In one study of the two-thirds game, participants who did two steps of strategic thinking showed more activity in the mentalizing circuit, suggesting that extra reasoning levels recruit the same network that tracks others' mental states, though Camerer calls for many more studies.373 | Colin Camerer on the Neuroscience of Economic Thinking
- The reliable experience of meeting seemingly autonomous entities under DMT does not establish that those entities or their 'other dimension' are independently real—just as dreams convince us of autonomous people every night—and the cross-cultural convergence on alien/reptilian beings is better explained by our shared neurobiology as a vision-and-socialization-primed species mentalizing a high-entropy state than by a literally real hyperspace.478 - The Psychedelic Mind
- Basic aspects of human cognition — our ability to read other minds and mentalize — make humans susceptible to dualism (thinking minds and bodies are separable); people who are better at mentalizing are more likely to believe in supernatural agents, providing the raw material that cultural evolution can act upon.Joseph Henrich