mental accounting
A behavioral-economics concept where people treat money differently depending on its source, conventionally labeled irrational.
As defined in Nassim Nicholas Taleb on Rationality, Risk, and Skin in the Game
Other definitions
A behavioral economics concept where people treat money differently based on its source (e.g., money won in a casino is treated differently than earned money), leading to apparent irrationality in decision-making
A conversation between Nassim Nicholas Taleb and Stephen Wolfram at the Wolfram Summer School 2021
Where it comes up · 6
- Nassim Taleb — Meditations on Extremistan2 claims
- Annie Duke on the Power of Quitting2 claims
- Nassim Taleb - The #1 Rule to Not Be a Sucker (The Ergodicity Principle)2 claims
- A conversation between Nassim Nicholas Taleb and Stephen Wolfram at the Wolfram Summer School 20211 claim
- Nassim Nicholas Taleb on Rationality, Risk, and Skin in the Game1 claim
- The Wealth Secrets No One Teaches You | Morgan Housel1 claim
Most important claims · 9 of 9Search all claims for “mental accounting” →
- Physical ledgers measure gains and losses from the starting line, but mental accounting measures from the finish line: even when you are objectively ahead (e.g. up $10 on a stock that peaked higher, or 13.1 miles into a marathon), you feel 'in the losses' relative to your goal, which distorts decisions about when to stop.Annie Duke on the Power of Quitting
- As Richard Thaler observed, people do not like to close mental accounts in the losses, which explains why someone continues past a turnaround time or reaches a summit hours late—they refuse to lock in the loss in their head even at the cost of their life.Annie Duke on the Power of Quitting
- Behavioral economics labels 'mental accounting'—treating won money differently from one's own money—irrational because it uses one-period models, but under a repeated-bets framework with a survival condition, mental accounting is not only rational but necessary, and any other strategy is irrational.Nassim Nicholas Taleb on Rationality, Risk, and Skin in the Game
- Thaler's concept of 'mental accounting' as a fallacy (treating money won at a casino as different from one's initial endowment) is actually correct behavior for survival: treating house money as distinct and being more aggressive with it than with one's endowment is the only way to survive, so what is labeled a psychological 'disease' is rational under ergodic dynamics.Nassim Taleb - The #1 Rule to Not Be a Sucker (The Ergodicity Principle)
- The mental accounting bias Richard Thaler discovered—that people treat 'house money' (winnings) differently from endowment—is actually rational and essential for survival; treating new wealth as different enables compounding and avoids ruin.A conversation between Nassim Nicholas Taleb and Stephen Wolfram at the Wolfram Summer School 2021
- Mental accounting—treating different money sources differently based on their origin—is irrational from a financial standpoint but can be psychologically useful when it enables better long-term behavior, such as saving all book royalties while spending freely from other income.The Wealth Secrets No One Teaches You | Morgan Housel
- Richard Thaler's central contribution to behavioral economics is identifying 'mental accounting'—the cognitive error of treating money won from a casino differently from initial endowment (called 'house money'), which is actually the correct survival strategy and shows people instinctively understand compounding even when economists call them irrational.Nassim Taleb - The #1 Rule to Not Be a Sucker (The Ergodicity Principle)
- Mental accounting—treating different sources of money differently depending on context (e.g., money won at a casino is 'house money' and is spent more freely)—is rational behavior with proper frequency analysis; Thaler's critique that this violates accounting standards misses that accounting standards don't apply to portfolio strategy and that the frequency of birthdays justifies the mental framing.Nassim Taleb — Meditations on Extremistan
- Mental accounting, where people treat winnings from a casino differently from initial capital and increase bets after winning (playing with house money), is rational because it protects against bankruptcy in negative expectation games.Nassim Taleb — Meditations on Extremistan