mens rea
The mental state or intent element required to establish criminal guilt, central to the debate over whether Trump 'knowingly' lied.
As defined in Ben Shapiro Destiny Debate
Where it comes up · 2
- 381 - Delusions Right And Left2 claims
- Ben Shapiro Destiny Debate2 claims
Most important claims · 4 of 4Search all claims for “mens rea” →
- Most people lack the foundational civic knowledge (e.g., the three branches of government, the role of electors, the function of state election officials) required to understand why certain acts are egregious norm violations, so abstract civic offenses like an inappropriate presidential phone call fail to register while visceral 'far-left' images register instantly.381 - Delusions Right And Left
- Trump's conduct between November 4 and January 6 was morally wrong and based on false claims, but it met neither the legal standard for incitement (incitement to immediate lawless action) nor insurrection (replacement of a legitimate government), as evidenced by the FBI finding no coordinated insurrectionist attempt and no one being charged with insurrection.Ben Shapiro Destiny Debate
- Trump's mental state regarding election fraud claims can be inferred the way criminal intent (mens rea) is established in any prosecution: there are numerous documented instances where he was told a claim was false and then repeated the identical claim days later, providing strong evidence he was knowingly lying.381 - Delusions Right And Left
- Whether Trump knew the election claims were false (required for the 'knowingly' intent element) is distinct from whether a reasonable person should have known; Trump has a unique capacity to convince himself of anything to his benefit, and Jack Smith's charging strategy—avoiding insurrection and seditious conspiracy—reflects his inability to establish the intent needed for those crimes.Ben Shapiro Destiny Debate