medical reversal
The phenomenon whereby an established medical practice, adopted on initial supporting evidence, is later found through rigorous testing to be ineffective or harmful and is reversed.
As defined in The Top EconTalk Conversations of 2023 (with Russ Roberts)
Where it comes up · 6
- Adam Cifu on Ending Medical Reversal5 claims
- Wide or Deep?1 claim
- Pedro Domingos on Machine Learning and the Master Algorithm1 claim
- John Ioannidis on Statistical Significance, Economics, and Replication1 claim
- Jacob Stegenga on Medical Nihilism1 claim
- The Top EconTalk Conversations of 2023 (with Russ Roberts)1 claim
Most important claims · 10 of 10Search all claims for “medical reversal” →
- Medical reversal occurs when a new therapy replaces an old one based on weak evidence, is adopted by thousands or millions of patients, and is then found—once more robust data emerges—to be no better than, or worse than, the old therapy or doing nothing.Adam Cifu on Ending Medical Reversal
- Interventions that look effective in observational studies often turn out to be ineffective or harmful when tested in randomized control trials, illustrating the general pattern that the better the methods get, the less effective interventions appear—a recurring trope in evidence-based medicine ('medical reversal').Jacob Stegenga on Medical Nihilism
- Ending Medical Reversal documents many standard practices adopted on intuition or weak evidence that better zoomed-out studies later overturned, yet they keep becoming more popular because specialists are tied to them even without financial compensation.Wide or Deep?
- Medical reversal occurs when a widely adopted practice based on an observational study—accepted because it was peer-reviewed—is later overturned by a randomized controlled trial that finds the opposite, showing the practice should not be done or that something else should be done instead.John Ioannidis on Statistical Significance, Economics, and Replication
- Cifu and Prasad labeled something a reversal only when the study overturning the practice was clearly more robust than the studies that had originally supported it—not merely a single contradicting study, which statistics guarantees will sometimes occur by chance.Adam Cifu on Ending Medical Reversal
- Reviewing all articles in The New England Journal of Medicine over a 10-year span identified 146 articles covering about 100 widely adopted therapies that turned out to be wrong; combined with other research this suggests as much as 35-40% of what medicine does could be wrong.Adam Cifu on Ending Medical Reversal
- Many procedures shown to be ineffective by superior studies continue to be performed because doctors believe they work or dispute the evidence, so reversal does not automatically end a practice.Adam Cifu on Ending Medical Reversal
- Many of the most common and widely implemented medical procedures, which originally started with some supporting evidence, are found upon careful testing not to work—or even to be harmful—a phenomenon called medical reversal.The Top EconTalk Conversations of 2023 (with Russ Roberts)
- The cure for medical reversal and treatments deployed on little evidence is to be more evidence-based: instead of basing decisions on one small study, machine learning lets us continuously gather feedback from treatment results as they roll out, dropping things that fail at scale and identifying the specific 5% of patients for whom a treatment actually works.Pedro Domingos on Machine Learning and the Master Algorithm
- Care from generalists tends to rest on solid evidence because common diseases are well studied, but as patients see more specialized physicians for rarer problems, the therapies are less well studied, patients are more willing to accept unproven treatments out of need, and specialists—often involved with the companies developing drugs and devices—are more willing to adopt therapies because they feel expert; this makes super-specialists' therapies among those most prone to reversal.Adam Cifu on Ending Medical Reversal