medical nihilism
The thesis that we ought to have low confidence in the effectiveness of modern medical interventions; a pronounced, deep form of skepticism about medicine.
As defined in Jacob Stegenga on Medical Nihilism
Where it comes up · 2
- Jacob Stegenga on Medical Nihilism3 claims
- Investing in Healthcare1 claim
Most important claims · 4 of 4Search all claims for “medical nihilism” →
- We ought to have low confidence in the effectiveness of modern medical interventions; a surprisingly large number of them are a bad idea because they either fail to achieve their goals or do so with offsetting harms.Jacob Stegenga on Medical Nihilism
- Medical nihilism is largely wrong because drugs save lives, as with his mother-in-law, but over-treatment is a genuine problem, with excess back surgery and prostate cancer biopsy and surgery producing harm beyond their benefit.Investing in Healthcare
- Medical nihilism can be read two ways: an epistemological thesis (current scientific methods aren't good enough to deliver what we want) or a stronger metaphysical thesis (the physical nature of bodies and drug action makes magic bullets impossible in principle for many diseases); Stegenga sits on the fence between them.Jacob Stegenga on Medical Nihilism
- Medical nihilism is not an anti-science position; it relies on high-quality science to make its case, and its target is poor reasoning based on low-quality, biased science exacerbated by financial conflicts of interest—indeed its arguments apply far more strongly to alternatives like homeopathy and the anti-vaccine movement than to mainstream medicine.Jacob Stegenga on Medical Nihilism