means testing
Restricting eligibility for a government benefit based on a recipient's income or assets; Galbraith opposes applying it to Social Security and Medicare.
As defined in James Galbraith on Inequality
Where it comes up · 4
- James Galbraith on Inequality2 claims
- 202 - A Conversation With Andrew Yang2 claims
- 189 - Wealth Happiness2 claims
- Todd Zywicki on Debt and Bankruptcy 03/02/20091 claim
Most important claims · 7 of 7Search all claims for “means testing” →
- Nearly everything in our society functions as an organized transfer of wealth from the young to the old: Social Security reallocates over a trillion dollars to the wealthiest generation in history, rising college costs and home prices price out the young, and deficit spending borrows prosperity from future generations to benefit current asset holders.189 - Wealth Happiness
- The 2005 bankruptcy reform required debtors to file detailed tax returns and schedules, because the previous honor system let people hide assets, such as cash in a shoebox, and report false income, and it imposed means testing on debtors whose income exceeds the state median and who could repay substantial debt.Todd Zywicki on Debt and Bankruptcy 03/02/2009
- Means-testing Social Security and Medicare is wrong because the solvency of a government program cannot be distinguished from the solvency of the government itself, so treating these programs as if they were private funds that must match payouts to FICA revenues far into the future is a mistake.James Galbraith on Inequality
- Social Security is a tax, not a savings account, with recipients taking out 3-6x what they paid in; for most it is not preventing poverty but funding a lifestyle upgrade, so it should be means tested so that the wealthy like Harris and Galloway are ineligible while assistance is concentrated on seniors actually in poverty.189 - Wealth Happiness
- A separate means test for Social Security and Medicare is unnecessary because the system already has a perfectly good means test—the progressive income tax—which makes people pay into government in relation to their means, so there is no need to layer an additional means test onto catastrophic health or old-age costs.James Galbraith on Inequality
- Universal basic income is superior to similar remedies because it removes the friction of means testing—rather than determining who qualifies in advance, the government should flood the zone with money to everyone, and recoup it later from the wealthy through taxes (claw it back in next year's tax returns).202 - A Conversation With Andrew Yang
- Government efforts to send money to people fail to reach tens of millions of the neediest Americans because the primary mechanism relies on prior tax returns, which excludes people who didn't file taxes (because they earned too little or worked in cash informal economies), and because systems like state unemployment offices were never designed to handle millions of simultaneous inquiries.202 - A Conversation With Andrew Yang