meaningful coincidence
Two or more events that occur simultaneously or in close temporal proximity and share symbolic or psychological meaning; the hallmark of synchronistic phenomena.
As defined in Carl Jung | Synchronicity | audiobook
Where it comes up · 1
Most important claims · 6 of 6Search all claims for “meaningful coincidence” →
- Jung argues that primitive consciousness does not distinguish between meaningful coincidence and magical causality; for primitives, synchronicity is a self-evident fact and there is no such thing as chance or accident—every event is attributed to magical influence (by a magician, a spirit, a soul); this primitive mentality views the world as organized by meaningful connections rather than efficient causes; in contrast, the medieval European mind maintained the correspondence theory while also maintaining causality, but the rise of modern science eliminated the correspondence theory entirely, leaving only causality as the principle of explanation.Carl Jung | Synchronicity | audiobook
- Derksen and Florian's statistical analysis of telepathic phenomena found a probability of 1 out of 4,114,545 that such precognitive warnings could be explained by chance, meaning the likelihood of chance explanation is 4 million times less probable than telepathic or acausal meaningful connection; the astronomer Flammarion calculated probability of 1 out of 84,622,222 for a particularly well-observed instance of phantasms of the living.Carl Jung | Synchronicity | audiobook
- Emotional affects and strong psychological states (fear, expectation, excitement) are the primary conditions enabling synchronistic phenomena; without emotional intensity constellating an archetype, meaningful coincidences do not reliably occur.Carl Jung | Synchronicity | audiobook
- On April 1, 1949, Jung observed an unusually high clustering of fish-related imagery and events within a 24-hour period: he noted an inscription about fish, a patient showed him impressive fish paintings she had made, he was shown embroidery with fish-like sea monsters, and another patient described a dream of a large fish swimming toward her and landing at her feet; Jung had been studying the fish symbol for months, and the suspicion that this was a meaningful coincidence (acausal connection) seemed very natural, though the clustering could statistically be explained by ordinary occurrence of fish references and coincidence.Carl Jung | Synchronicity | audiobook
- Schopenhauer believed the simultaneity of causally unconnected events (meaningful coincidences) could be explained through the concept of a single first cause (transcendental will or Primal Cause), which would act as a unified principle organizing all events; however, this explanation requires assuming absolute determinism of natural processes and a first cause, neither of which can be empirically proven, and if the first cause were actually a multiplicity rather than a unity, Schopenhauer's entire explanation collapses.Carl Jung | Synchronicity | audiobook
- The tram ticket bearing the same number as a theater ticket purchased immediately afterward, followed by that same number appearing again in a telephone call the same evening, represents such an improbable causal connection that it is more reasonable to posit an acausal principle of meaningful coincidence.Carl Jung | Synchronicity | audiobook