mathematical realism
The philosophical view that mathematical objects exist independently of human minds and are discovered rather than invented.
As defined in AMA | April 2025
Where it comes up · 4
- 137 | Justin Clarke-Doane on Mathematics, Morality, Objectivity, and Reality4 claims
- AMA | April 20252 claims
- AMA | February 20221 claim
- AMA | May 20251 claim
Most important claims · 8 of 8Search all claims for “mathematical realism” →
- When it comes to realism, moral realism is on every bit as good footing as mathematical realism, because the obvious dis-analogies do not survive scrutiny: that math settles things once and for all with proof while ethics argues endlessly, that math gets applied to the physical world with no moral analog, and that we can explain our moral beliefs via evolution without appealing to their truth while having no such explanation in the mathematical case — none of these marks a deep dis-analogy.137 | Justin Clarke-Doane on Mathematics, Morality, Objectivity, and Reality
- Accepting Everett's many-worlds interpretation does not require believing that useful mathematical models reflect or are physical reality; rather, one takes the wave function as the best description of a physical world that exists independently, so realism about the quantum state is distinct from Platonist realism about mathematics, and the two are not a package deal.AMA | April 2025
- Even though number theory results like Lagrange's Four Square Theorem and prime number patterns feel like discoveries of an independent objective landscape, this is compatible with mathematical anti-realism, because once axioms and definitions are fixed, their logical consequences are determined and feel discovered without requiring that mathematical objects exist in the same way physical things do.AMA | April 2025
- Given that physicists select specific mathematical structures (Hilbert space, spacetime manifolds) to describe the world, the question is what elevates any specific mathematical structure to being 'real,' distinguishing it from other abstract possibilities suggested by mathematical realism, and how one can justify believing in just one structure without believing in all of them.AMA | May 2025
- Although mathematics and morality seem totally different on the surface, under close examination there are surprising similarities between the case for realism about each — the case for the existence of independent facts of the matter — which becomes an important question for naturalists deciding whether one can consistently be a mathematical realist while being a moral anti-realist.137 | Justin Clarke-Doane on Mathematics, Morality, Objectivity, and Reality
- Mathematical realism is the view that mathematical statements of the sort encountered in ordinary math classes (number theory, geometry, set theory) have truth values — they can be true or false — and whether they are true is not up to us; we cannot change our conventions to make the twin primes conjecture false, even though we can mean different things by the same symbols.137 | Justin Clarke-Doane on Mathematics, Morality, Objectivity, and Reality
- A naturalistically inclined philosopher or scientist tends to accept independent mathematical facts because science is saturated with mathematics and it is hard to know what it could mean to believe physical theories but not math as independent reality, while simultaneously rejecting independent moral facts because science seems to have no need for them — moral norms being explicable through evolutionary stories about why establishing conduct norms benefited our ancestors.137 | Justin Clarke-Doane on Mathematics, Morality, Objectivity, and Reality
- One's philosophical stance on mathematical realism vs nominalism—whether numbers are as real as electrons or merely a way of talking about the physical world—is not idle, because it changes how a theorist develops further theories; Carroll's nominalist leanings have led him to contemplate physics theories using only mathematics weak enough not to invoke their own consistency, illustrating how metaphysical stances feed back into actual research.AMA | February 2022