lockdown
A broad term for government-imposed restrictions ranging from stay-at-home orders to closure of businesses, schools, and gathering places, with widely varying severity.
As defined in Don Boudreaux on the Pandemic
Where it comes up · 3
- Don Boudreaux on the Pandemic5 claims
- Emily Oster on the Pandemic1 claim
- 335 - A Postmortem On My Response To Covid1 claim
Most important claims · 7 of 7Search all claims for “lockdown” →
- Even granting that lockdowns reduced COVID cases, hospitalizations, and deaths, and even if the benefits of lives saved exceeded the costs, that still would not prove the measures were appropriate, because the Coasean point is that if a lower-cost way of dealing with the problem existed—such as focused protection—then that better set of actions is the one we should have taken.Don Boudreaux on the Pandemic
- By at least June 2020 it was known that lockdowns were not working, and the overwhelming weight of evidence is that lockdowns have essentially no effect on the spread of the virus, slowing it at most a tiny amount.Don Boudreaux on the Pandemic
- The strongest justification ever given for lockdowns was the early 'flatten the curve' rationale: given a fixed, limited supply of emergency rooms and ventilators in March 2020, harsh measures may have been the best way to avoid overwhelming hospitals, regardless of whether that capacity limit was itself the product of unwise prior government policy.Don Boudreaux on the Pandemic
- Sweden's no-lockdown approach initially looked bad—death rates higher than Norway and Denmark—and that judgment hinged on whether a vaccine was imminent; but once it became clear no vaccine was coming soon, Sweden saw less of a second wave, and it remains unclear how much is herd immunity, learned behaviors, or testing differences, illustrating that evaluating lockdown policy requires a long time horizon.Emily Oster on the Pandemic
- Neil Ferguson's Imperial College model predicted enormous fatalities and was treated as scientific gospel, and after Ferguson observed that China could implement lockdowns he advised the British government to do so, which catalyzed the world's shift away from longstanding public-health advice against general lockdowns toward universal lockdown.Don Boudreaux on the Pandemic
- Voluntarily avoiding large crowded indoor gatherings while a contagious respiratory disease is spreading—as with super-spreader events like a church choir where many got infected and died—is a reasonable response, and is distinct from coercively shutting down the entire economy except essential workers.Don Boudreaux on the Pandemic
- Despite US concerns about censorship, America has much stronger free-speech protections than almost anywhere else, and US lockdowns lasted only five to seven weeks on average depending on the state, whereas countries like New Zealand, Australia, and Canada locked down much harder at most stages.335 - A Postmortem On My Response To Covid