liberal (classical sense)
Devoted to liberty—protection of property, civil, and political rights—as opposed to the modern American political meaning of the word.
As defined in Christopher Coyne on Exporting Democracy after War 04/07/2008
Where it comes up · 1
Most important claims · 10 of 10Search all claims for “liberal (classical sense)” →
- Even if Iraqi groups could move toward a larger economic pie under liberal democracy, the uncertainty over each group's future share, combined with the need to set dividing rules in advance, causes fighting that leads parties to forgo the gains they could otherwise achieve—a coordination/bargaining failure.Christopher Coyne on Exporting Democracy after War 04/07/2008
- We know the ingredient list of liberal democracy (property rights, civil rights, political rights, rule of law) but not the recipe to create it where it doesn't exist; the implication is that since we don't know how to cook it, we should not cook in the first place—i.e., we should be highly skeptical of intervention.Christopher Coyne on Exporting Democracy after War 04/07/2008
- Japan and West Germany are not evidence of an American ability to centrally plan liberal democratic institutions; they are evidence of the ability to overthrow a regime (where the U.S. military excels) combined with recognizing and utilizing indigenous institutions (Japan) or, in Germany, succeeding despite imposed drags on the economy.Christopher Coyne on Exporting Democracy after War 04/07/2008
- Unilateral free trade is a better tool of change than isolation/sanctions toward illiberal regimes: economic sanctions rarely if ever produce regime change, typically hurt the country's citizens by blocking goods, and give bad leaders fodder to blame the U.S.; trade is voluntary and offers both economic gains and cultural exposure to the values and ideals underpinning a free society, though it is not a panacea.Christopher Coyne on Exporting Democracy after War 04/07/2008
- Democracy is merely a mechanism for electing people (majority rule), which by itself is not good; what makes democracy beneficial to human beings is liberal constraints—protection of property, civil and political rights, and binding constraints on rulers so neither majorities nor elites can exploit citizens. Hamas is a democracy but not a free society.Christopher Coyne on Exporting Democracy after War 04/07/2008
- People respond to incentives: raising the benefit of a behavior produces more of it, raising the cost produces less; therefore reconstruction is fundamentally about whether occupiers can create rules that give citizens the incentive to pursue ends aligned with liberal democracy, and when those incentives are absent the reconstructed institutions unravel.Christopher Coyne on Exporting Democracy after War 04/07/2008
- In Iraq the historical animosities and centuries-old conflicts among groups and subgroups (Kurds, Sunni, Shia and their subfactions) raise the transaction and bargaining costs of forming a cooperative liberal-democratic settlement, because parties do not trust each other and have violently coerced one another in the past.Christopher Coyne on Exporting Democracy after War 04/07/2008
- Westerners have a fetish for nation-states and assume any government is better than none, but when the feasibility set does not contain liberal democracy, propping up weak or failed governments yields very bad outcomes; there is a good argument for allowing weak and failed states to fully collapse, because such governments are a pure cost on citizens benefiting only cronies, and a state weakening or collapsing signals it is not providing goods people want.Christopher Coyne on Exporting Democracy after War 04/07/2008
- A liberal democracy of the form the West wants will not emerge in Iraq in the near future; the best achievable outcome is some kind of stability once the relative power relations between groups become clear, and that cooperative equilibrium is unlikely to be one the U.S. would view as good.Christopher Coyne on Exporting Democracy after War 04/07/2008
- U.S. interventions throughout Latin America and Cuba installed regimes friendly to U.S. political and business interests even when those regimes were illiberal, creating a tension between the rhetoric of spreading liberty and self-determination and the reality of picking winners at the expense of the country's citizens.Christopher Coyne on Exporting Democracy after War 04/07/2008