kludge
A term from computer programming for an ill-assorted collection of parts assembled to fulfill a particular purpose -- a clumsy but temporarily effective solution to a fault or problem.
As defined in Steven Teles on Kludgeocracy
Where it comes up · 1
- Steven Teles on Kludgeocracy7 claims
Most important claims · 7 of 7Search all claims for “kludge” →
- The original constitutional design (separation of powers, filibuster) is well-suited to a people with modest expectations of the federal government, but once public expectations shift to a mature set of government functions, that design works opposite to libertarian intentions: any maturing government will develop new functions, and a desirable one destroys old programs while adding new ones, but the American system is wired for creation and bad at destruction, which is precisely why it produces kludge.Steven Teles on Kludgeocracy
- By pushing down effectively on the visible supply of government (taxing and spending), conservatives and libertarians have not reduced the demand for government but merely constrained one form of its supply -- so like pressing down on a down pillow, the demand pops up elsewhere through litigation, mandates, and regulation (e.g., carbon-tax opposition leading to complicated EV subsidies and light-bulb regulations); the better strategy is to loosen up on the measurable form (taxing and spending) while constraining the forms we cannot measure or control.Steven Teles on Kludgeocracy
- Much of what government does is kludge -- adding new programs on top of existing ones because it is too hard to eliminate what already exists, producing complex systems that are hard for citizens to understand and that obscure who is responsible when problems arise.Steven Teles on Kludgeocracy
- Big complicated multi-layered systems are themselves forms of taxation that don't pass through the federal budget but impose costs on private actors, making goods more expensive -- hidden forms of extraction that are hard to mobilize against because, unlike direct taxing and spending, we cannot measure who pays or who benefits.Steven Teles on Kludgeocracy
- Conservatives should dislike kludge because when government is everywhere and nowhere -- penetrating the tax code, private litigation, and private enterprise -- it becomes like trying to stab gelatin to the wall: those who want to remove government from particular areas cannot get hold of a target diffused across hidden mechanisms.Steven Teles on Kludgeocracy
- Liberals should dislike kludge because hidden, complex forms of government (subsidy, regulation, market structure) lead citizens -- especially the middle class -- to experience government assistance as private and not recognize their dependence on government, so simpler, more visible programs would make clear how much social welfare depends on a muscular role for government.Steven Teles on Kludgeocracy
- Liberals should stop negotiating with themselves by cutting private interests in on the action and instead pursue simple, transparent programs (e.g., Medicare for all rather than the ACA's exchanges), making the social-justice case openly to the public and accepting they may lose -- because they will be blamed anyway when the complexity of hybrid programs makes them look bad.Steven Teles on Kludgeocracy