judicial warrant
A court order, typically requiring probable cause, that authorizes police to conduct a search or seize evidence that would otherwise violate a privacy expectation.
As defined in 347 | Andrew Guthrie Ferguson on How Your Data Will Be Used Against You
Where it comes up · 1
Most important claims · 6 of 6Search all claims for “judicial warrant” →
- Judicial warrants are 'weak sauce' protection: they only require probable cause, which is well below the 51% preponderance standard—you can be wrong, perhaps right only in the 30% range, and still get a warrant—and they only require a criminal predicate, so if newly-criminalized conduct like protesting becomes a predicate, your data becomes obtainable.347 | Andrew Guthrie Ferguson on How Your Data Will Be Used Against You
- Even relatively privacy-protective US companies like Amazon cannot refuse a lawful subpoena or warrant because the legal structure compels compliance, and their interests are further conflicted by federal government contracts and shareholder obligations, so consumer-facing goodwill does not shield user data from law enforcement.347 | Andrew Guthrie Ferguson on How Your Data Will Be Used Against You
- Whether something counts as a Fourth Amendment 'search' turns on whether it violates a 'reasonable expectation of privacy' (established in United States v. Katz); your home clearly qualifies and requires a warrant, but it is an open question whether data you store with a third-party cloud provider like Google or Amazon still carries that expectation.347 | Andrew Guthrie Ferguson on How Your Data Will Be Used Against You
- There is no data so private that police cannot obtain it with a warrant—your smart bed, digital diary, period-tracking app, even a smart pacemaker readout—so the most intimate self-generated data can become evidence, which Ferguson argues is not the right balance.347 | Andrew Guthrie Ferguson on How Your Data Will Be Used Against You
- When the Supreme Court interprets new technology under old law—such as requiring a warrant to search a smartphone because of the highly private information it holds—it often pleads with Congress to regulate, but Congress has largely failed to act, leaving courts to stretch a 1791 document to govern modern surveillance.347 | Andrew Guthrie Ferguson on How Your Data Will Be Used Against You
- We could have the best of both worlds—full consumer convenience plus protection—if police could only access intimate self-generated data under a heightened standard beyond a simple criminal-predicate warrant, and this is plausibly in companies' interest since selling technology while requiring law enforcement to clear a higher bar does not affect their business.347 | Andrew Guthrie Ferguson on How Your Data Will Be Used Against You