isolated demand for rigor
A rhetorical fallacy of demanding an unusually high or specific standard of proof for one claim while not applying it to comparable claims.
As defined in Zvi Mowshowitz on AI and the Dial of Progress
Where it comes up · 1
Most important claims · 1 of 1Search all claims for “isolated demand for rigor” →
- Tyler Cowen's demand for a formal model akin to climate models is an isolated demand for a very specific kind of rigor that doesn't match what truth-seeking requires for inherently social, intelligence-based dynamics involving systems smarter than ourselves and unknown technological capabilities; a single formal model wouldn't convince many people, and because different people 'get off the train' at different objections, one would have to build dozens of models rather than one.Zvi Mowshowitz on AI and the Dial of Progress