intersex
People whose biological/physiological sex characteristics are not clearly male or female in the traditional sense
As defined in AMA | December 2022
Where it comes up · 5
- 3 | Alice Dreger on Sexuality, Truth, and Justice9 claims
- 135 - Navigating Sex And Gender2 claims
- 109 - Biology And Culture1 claim
- 182 | Sally Haslanger on Social Construction and Critical Theory1 claim
- AMA | December 20221 claim
Most important claims · 10 of 14Search all claims for “intersex” →
- Sex in humans involves at least four distinct dimensions that operate simultaneously: biological sex (the body), gender identity (how one thinks of oneself as male or female), gender expression (clothing, mannerisms), and sexual orientation (whom one is attracted to); intersex concerns biological sex while transgenderism concerns gender identity.3 | Alice Dreger on Sexuality, Truth, and Justice
- A person cannot be born with two complete sets of genitals because all humans begin with the same single set of undifferentiated parts that develop down a male, female, or intermediate route; structures like the penis and clitoris, or the scrotum and labia majora, are the same organ developing differently, so one can have parts of both types or a blend but never two complete sets.3 | Alice Dreger on Sexuality, Truth, and Justice
- Intersex people and transgender people historically had opposite problems for the same underlying reason: intersex people received sex-change operations they never asked for while transgender people struggled to obtain the operations they did want, but both suffered from a patriarchal medical system that arrogated to itself the authority to decide what people would look like and what sex they were.3 | Alice Dreger on Sexuality, Truth, and Justice
- Beginning in earnest in the 1950s, intersex children were subjected to normalizing genital surgeries premised on the unproven belief that anyone left sexually in-between would become miserable and suicidal; this produced generations of people who were lied to about their medical history, left with surgical complications, and sometimes rendered infertile, and the doctors—though well-intentioned—operated with extremely bad follow-up science about whether the interventions worked.3 | Alice Dreger on Sexuality, Truth, and Justice
- While doctors are now more aware of intersex activists' concerns, the practice has not changed enough; instead of surgeons taking responsibility for decisions, the system now frames it as the parents' decision while still pressuring them toward surgery, so in many places the same interventions continue with parents bearing the blame, whereas reformist clinicians who recommend leaving bodies intact and preserving bodily autonomy find parents comfortable waiting.3 | Alice Dreger on Sexuality, Truth, and Justice
- The Olympic Committee inconsistently allows athletes to keep most inborn genetic advantages (such as height in basketball or superior oxygen processing) while singling out naturally high androgen levels in women for prohibition, and they compound this by attempting to measure hormone effects on tissues that cannot yet be reliably measured, so the better solution is to admit there are simply two gender categories and stop trying to police biology.3 | Alice Dreger on Sexuality, Truth, and Justice
- Because sex is central to evolution as the mechanism by which genes are recombined, sex development is necessarily a complex developmental process, and any biologically important complex process will produce variation, including at least thirty-plus distinct ways of developing in terms of sex, arising both from random developmental events and from genetic conditions running in families.3 | Alice Dreger on Sexuality, Truth, and Justice
- The sex binary is not simply given: there is a broad spectrum of bodies, intersex people, people who in different cultures count as neither category, and the very definition of sex is socially variable — so sex itself is partly socially categorized, complicating the simple sex/gender distinction.182 | Sally Haslanger on Social Construction and Critical Theory
- Pediatric endocrinologist Maria New, a National Academy of Sciences member, convinced pregnant women at risk for having intersex daughters to take the steroid dexamethasone to prevent intersex development, telling families it had been found safe for mother and child while simultaneously obtaining NIH grant money on the claim that she needed to study those same families to determine whether it was safe or effective—using the same population recruited under a safety assurance to investigate that very safety, which Dreger considered a serious ethical violation.3 | Alice Dreger on Sexuality, Truth, and Justice
- Gender and sex are not identical—gender is the software of sex. Sexes are bimodal (two modes) rather than strictly binary, and those modes usually line up with two genders, but considerable variation doesn't fit, some from chromosomally intersex people and some at the software level. Because we are software-based creatures living in evolutionarily novel circumstances, our developmental environments deliver abnormal, untested information whose effect on gender identity we cannot yet specify, so the biological question is open while the moral imperative—compassion, no signing up for fiction—is clear.109 - Biology And Culture