insurance company model
Chapin's name for the dominant US health care arrangement in which health care is financed exclusively through insurance companies that pay physicians fee-for-service while (originally) being forbidden from supervising medical practice.
As defined in Christy Ford Chapin on the Evolution of the American Health Care System
Where it comes up · 1
Most important claims · 5 of 5Search all claims for “insurance company model” →
- Facing New Deal reform pressure, AMA leaders fabricated the insurance company model out of thin air at the end of the 1930s as a 'private market' alternative to government action: they would finally allow health insurance but only through insurance companies (not unions, cooperatives, or physician groups), require fee-for-service payment, ban multi-specialty groups, and forbid insurers from questioning or supervising physician practice—forcing insurers to fund a service whose supply they could neither control nor forecast.Christy Ford Chapin on the Evolution of the American Health Care System
- The insurance company model spread not because it was efficient or cheap, but because physicians and insurers self-consciously raced to expand coverage and benefits to present 'progress reports' to Congress and thereby preempt federal reform efforts (Truman, Eisenhower), even while insurers lost money and subsidized health lines from their property/casualty and life underwriting.Christy Ford Chapin on the Evolution of the American Health Care System
- Health care cost inflation was not caused by Medicare's 1965 passage; as soon as the insurance company model took hold by the late 1940s, the health care component rose faster than any other category in the consumer price index, showing the model itself drove costs.Christy Ford Chapin on the Evolution of the American Health Care System
- The American health care system is not what would have naturally evolved out of competitive markets; before the AMA's intervention there were numerous competing models (union plans, consumer cooperatives, mutual aid societies, prepaid physician groups), some highly efficient, which were suppressed rather than outcompeted.Christy Ford Chapin on the Evolution of the American Health Care System
- Under the current insurance company model physicians are paid per service and procedure, which incentivizes over-utilization because billing requires doing something; non-billable activities like spending time with a patient, phone calls, or emails generate no payment, so doctors are driven to perform procedures rather than provide care generally.Christy Ford Chapin on the Evolution of the American Health Care System