instrumental variables
An econometric technique using a variable correlated with the cause but not the outcome (except through the cause) to estimate causal effects; cited in Gruber's religion study.
As defined in Patrick Collison
Where it comes up · 6
- Joshua Angrist on Econometrics and Causation3 claims
- James Heckman on Facts, Evidence, and the State of Econometrics2 claims
- Patrick Collison1 claim
- 165 | Kathryn Paige Harden on Genetics, Luck, and Fairness1 claim
- 287 | Jean-Paul Faguet on Institutions and the Legacy of History1 claim
- Ed Leamer on the State of Econometrics 05/10/20101 claim
Most important claims · 9 of 9Search all claims for “instrumental variables” →
- Instrumental variables / natural experiments are 'accidental experiments' that exploit exotic events (like the Mariel boatlift) presumed uncorrelated with the outcome being studied, but every such instrument opens a conversation about whether it is truly a legitimate randomized treatment or is in fact correlated with the response.Ed Leamer on the State of Econometrics 05/10/2010
- To rule out that better development reflects pre-existing 'locational fundamentals' (good soil, water, trade routes) rather than the encomienda, the researchers use neighbor-pair fixed effects (comparing adjacent municipalities where one had encomienda and one did not, so unmeasured local characteristics cancel out) plus an instrumental variable—the least-cost path of the conquistadores reconstructed from a 1560 imperial agent's records and NASA geographic data—which correlates with encomienda presence but not directly with modern outcomes.287 | Jean-Paul Faguet on Institutions and the Legacy of History
- Randomization can be understood as a special case of an instrumental variable: it moves people toward treatment or control while assuming it balances unobservables across the two groups, so an experiment is one type of instrument rather than a fundamentally different method.James Heckman on Facts, Evidence, and the State of Econometrics
- Religion is a special form of cultural capital that, even adjusting for income, has predictive power over birth rates; secular societies fall into much lower birth rates and fail to reproduce themselves, which is among the most damning things about a society, and America's persistently strong religiosity for its income level helps keep its population stable or growing.Patrick Collison
- The goal should be to make genetics 'boring'—a routine technique (using polygenic scores, sibling, or twin designs) incorporated into everyday developmental, clinical, and educational psychology research like propensity score matching or instrumental variables analysis, to refine the rigor of inferences and identify which environments are most efficacious at producing desired outcomes in children.165 | Kathryn Paige Harden on Genetics, Luck, and Fairness
- Because oversubscribed charter schools allocate seats by lottery, researchers can compare students offered versus not offered seats and use instrumental variables to adjust for actual attendance, yielding a credible causal estimate of charter school effects.Joshua Angrist on Econometrics and Causation
- The Minneapolis domestic violence experiment, where police were randomly encouraged but not forced to arrest suspected batterers, is an instrumental-variables situation because the treatment cannot be fully dictated, making IV the ideal tool for the messy partial-compliance common in social field trials.Joshua Angrist on Econometrics and Causation
- Regression is not the best method but the natural starting point; any credible empirical paper on cause and effect should at least show controlled regression estimates as a first word, even if not the last word.Joshua Angrist on Econometrics and Causation
- Instrumental variables, central to the so-called credibility revolution, are not new techniques—they trace back to Philip Wright or Sewall Wright around 1928 and have been a central part of econometrics for 70-80 years.James Heckman on Facts, Evidence, and the State of Econometrics